wow talk about prescient!
http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=14410&perpage=6&pagenumber=36Quote from steve46:
07-02-06 07:33 PM
Had occasion to speak with Mr. Neiderhoffer several times during my training. Certainly he was an intelligent person, and I have no knowledge of him socially. The gentleman who trained me did know him socially and his comment "The man's an odd duck"....
I found over the years, that it does not take tremendous intellect to have success in the markets, but rather a combination of intellect, discipline and the ability to put things in context. I have mentioned the need for "context" in a couple of my posts recently. Without it a smart person can think him/herself into a corner, finding themselves at a dead end. That is what happened to to this guy. Except for the celebrity he was able to cultivate along the way, and his family's money, he would be out on the street today, looking for a job at a boutique firm.
There are many intelligent, competent professionals working for Wall Street firms who obtain excellent results on a consistent basis. YOU FOLKS do not hear of them, because their are people WITH MONEY who do not want you to know they exist. Mr.Neiderhoffer is old news. A guy who had promise but couldn't maintain his discipline. In this business it is the equivalent of falling on your sword. You only do it once.
Naturally there are (still) Neiderhoffer "groupies" on the fringes of the financial community, and just like the empty headed rock groupies, these folks generally have not had much in the way of success on their own. They tend to believe that this man has some mojo that might rub off on them if them just stand close enough. Aint gonna happen.
I wouldn't pay 10 cents for his book.
Steve