Nearly Random Entry vs a High Probability Entry

Status
Not open for further replies.
Anything taken from ANY CHATROOM _IS_ BS as far as a trade that was made or not. It means nothing. No one can tell what is a paper trade or not.

In fact, anything taken from a message board is to be taken with the slightest grain of salt.

Susan, sorry for getting your hopes up - I doubt you will get any takers, as is becoming more and more evident.

nitro
Quote from inandlong:

Does having money on the line make the truth more valid? No. Posting the trades in the chatroom where everyone who is interested can watch for free is perfectly fine.

If it isn't, then from now on the members posting their trades, profits and losses in the chatroom should be considered to be full of BS because they have not set up an independent reviewer to verify their claims for all to see. Y' know, it's the old "what's good for the goose is good for the gander" thing.

Maybe we should ask Baron for a button to push in the chatroom that would automatically put "Oh yeah... prove it" on the screen. Or we can continue to take people for their word and not presume that anything other than "I am a loser" is a lie.

Funny, in all of the posts and threads where members claim to have lost money, no one ever says "I don't believe you", or "Oh yeah right, I'll bet", or some other similar remark. But let a guy post that he made money or makes money, and the crap responses can't be posted fast enough. Does this phenomenon occur because all have lost money, but not all have made or make money?

I think so.

LOL! I was just thinking.... only those members who post gains in the chatroom should be considered to be full of BS. The ones posting losses are definitely telling the truth.
More...
 
Quote from inandlong:

Posting the trades in the chatroom where everyone who is interested can watch for free is perfectly fine.

More...

Let's do it! :D (Even paper-trading would be good enough to start as the first step! However, Nitro has a good point!)
 
Anything taken from ANY CHATROOM IS BS as far as a trade that was made or not.
More...
Foolish me. I thought that members posting their trades in the chat room at ET were posting actual trades. I guess not. Of course you can only speak for yourself regarding the matter. So the natural conclusion is that the trades you post in the chatroom are BS.

And it is played out so well. I mean the number of times I have posted 'way to go' when a member posts a profit, and he replies "Thanks". And come to find out it has all been BS. What is there ...some sort of conspiracy in the chatroom that everyone posts BS?

It's a dark day in Mudville my friends.... a very dark day.

But as far as damir goes, if he posts it in the chatroom real time, and trades it real time, that's good enough for me. And I suspect most other people as well. You can't BS real time. It doesn't matter if the trade was actually taken or not.
 
Quote from inandlong:

Foolish me. I thought that members posting their trades in the chat room at ET were posting actual trades. I guess not. Of course you can only speak for yourself regarding the matter. So the natural conclusion is that the trades you post in the chatroom are BS.

And it is played out so well. I mean the number of times I have posted 'way to go' when a member posts a profit, and he replies "Thanks". And come to find out it has all been BS. What is there ...some sort of conspiracy in the chatroom that everyone posts BS?

It's a dark day in Mudville my friends.... a very dark day.
More...

It's the pits to be the last to know, isn't it? :eek:
 
You are correct. The trades in _ANY_ chatroom are _BS_ unless backed up by AUDITED STATEMENTS.

If you felt that I made a nice trade when posted to the chatroom and wanted to thank me for it, I will gladly accept your kindness in turn. HOWEVER, if you ever wanted to hand me your good earned money to trade on your behalf, I STRONGLY SUGGEST YOU ASK FOR AUDITED STATEMENTS.

nitro

Quote from inandlong:

Foolish me. I thought that members posting their trades in the chat room at ET were posting actual trades. I guess not. Of course you can only speak for yourself regarding the matter. So the natural conclusion is that the trades you post in the chatroom are BS.

And it is played out so well. I mean the number of times I have posted 'way to go' when a member posts a profit, and he replies "Thanks". And come to find out it has all been BS. What is there ...some sort of conspiracy in the chatroom that everyone posts BS?

It's a dark day in Mudville my friends.... a very dark day.
More...
 
Quote from nitro:

HOWEVER, if you ever wanted to hand me your good earned money to trade on your behalf, I STRONGLY SUGGEST YOU ASK FOR AUDITED STATEMENTS.

nitro
More...

Very well said, Nitro. Thanks!:)
 
Quote from J~Commisso:

Damir,

Instead of swinging your dick around in this thread -- why don't you simply try to explain to others how you managed to close (55 out of 57) profitable trades in August using a random entry generator???

PEACE and good-trading,
Commisso
More...

You don't believe it? C'mon... :D don't be so skeptical!
Here's a quote from Damir's journal:

NoiseBox Summary, August 2003
All Trades : 57
Winning Trades : 55
Losing Trades : 2
Total %Gain/Loss : 9.4%
Avg %Gain/Loss : 0.16%
Avg Win% : 0.2%
Avg Loss% : -0.2%

For a profit factor of *only*... 27.5
What a joke.
 
Quote from DT-waw:



You don't believe it? C'mon... :D don't be so skeptical!
Here's a quote from Damir's journal:

NoiseBox Summary, August 2003
All Trades : 57
Winning Trades : 55
Losing Trades : 2
Total %Gain/Loss : 9.4%
Avg %Gain/Loss : 0.16%
Avg Win% : 0.2%
Avg Loss% : -0.2%

For a profit factor of *only*... 27.5
What a joke.
More...

Well I think damir00 can speak for himself, anyway I can witness his trades for August were all posted in realtime on #indexfutures and on his thread in ET
Obviously I don't know if they were real or paper trades.
It's a joke?
well tell me more of these jokes, I'm all ears. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top