Quote from flytiger:
4. If I'm naked short or short OSTK at $45, and he tenders at $18, I just buy in all day long at 18. There is never a squeeze, unless he tenders higher then 45.
Why does it bother you that someone did his homework well enough to know that $45 was a ridiculous price for a company?
Doesn't he have the same chance of being wrong as anyone else?
Of course there would be a squeeze, if the company was actually worth more than what it is trading at. The armies of funds will spot the free money in real time right in their spreadsheets.
The tiny number of shortsellers cannot compete with legions of institional funds.