Quote from hajimow:
Which trade you would take? Look at the following two cases and their possible profits or losses and let me know which one you would pick as your trade. I will put the average of bid and ask as the premium and will ignore commission.
Case 1: Sell Call and PUT TXN 32.5 for Jan.
You will get $1.50 for Call and $1.35 for PUT. Total of $2.85. Margin needed will be 20% x 32.5 x 100=$650 per contract.
We assume that TXN is at 32.5 now.
Case 2: Sell Call 35 and Put 27.5 both for Jan.
You will get $0.575 for Call and $0.175 for Put . Total of $0.75
Margin needed will be (20% x 32.5- 2.5) x 100=$400 per contract.
Some more info. Six month chart of TXN shows low of about 27.2 and max of 34.
Max gain in case one is 285/650 x 100=44% which is almost impossible. If it closes at 34,your profit would be 135/650 x 100=20% and if it closes at 27.2, your loss will be -245/650 x100= -38%
Max gain in case two is 75/400 x100=19% which is quite possible. If it closes at 34, you will still get 19% profit and if it closes at 27.2, your gain would be 45/400= 11%. You will only lose if it goes over 35.75 or below 26.75.
Untrained eyes will hate Case 2 as you are dealing with nickle and dime but $2.85 looks attractive in Case 1. I would definitely go with Case 2. (nickel and dime case)
If one of the days before option expiry date shit happens and stock goes up or down like $10, in both cases you are smoked. In that case, putting money under pillow would be the best choice.