Quote from Put_Master:
<<< If I read you correctly,it is not the concept of selling spreads that ruffles your feathers, it is way of "spread traders". It appears that your basic argument is spread traders are overleveraged,have no regard for initial delta and are out of control. >>>
That would be a reasonable summation.
But the part about being out of control, refers back to them being over leveraged. However, it's not so much that they are over leveraged, per their "choice".
It's more along the line that most spread traders don't even know they are leveraged at all!
Let alone leveraged at 5... 10... 15 or even 20 times the value of their account.
Danshirley is a perfect example of that. He's been doing spreads for years, and had no idea he was even on leverage at all.
He spent several weeks arguing with me, telling me that i was crazy, and that he is NOT on margin. That there is no margin with spreads.
He finally asked his broker and apologized to me. He may have even thanked me for pointing it out to him.
I have no idea how leveraged he was, but he was selling a lot of spreads in the 40, 50 and 60 area.
GULP!
Now Dan doesn't do just credit spreads. He uses a variety of strategies. While his account was at more risk than he was aware of, it was not in the insane crazy degree of leverage, that traders who specialize in credit spreads are in.
A spread here and there is one thing. But a portfolio of "all" or even "mostly" spreads is another.
Those are the folks who need to be educated and warned.
THose are the accounts that can drop to zero in no time, during difficult times.
Most simply don't realize, that the "limited risk" of credit spreads, which is the aspect about them they find so apppealing,... refers to their account value. That their account value can not drop below zero.
They are overly focused on the limited risk "per trade", and NOT how too many of those individual trades going bad at once, can devastate their account value.
WHY?
Because they are over leveraged and don't know it. Hence their only choice during difficult times, is to sell for a loss.
If you are trading spreads as a strategy, you have no plan "B", for 90% of your trades, during difficult times.
It's actually more than 90%, but I'll save that discussion for another day.
you guys sure know how to beat a subject to death!