In the long run, you'd have to be REALLY BAD to not be able to hit at least either a 50% win rate with a 1.1 RR or a 25% win rate with a 3.1 RR on a single asset trading just once a day. That's probably worse than random. It's pretty much a casino that trends. How can you not make money buying dips in an uptrend, or selling rips in a downtrend.
(Answer: your stops and your entries suck. Easy problem to solve in both cases)
Indeed, my conclusion is that OP has no real viable system. He should stop everything and go back to the drawing board to build a real and profitable system before doing anything. Earn to trade or any similar thing is just a waste of money.
If he wants to try something, he should open an account at Ninjatrader for less than $1,000, receive free realtime datafeed, and trade just one contract MES till he can proof his consistency. With $1,000 he can lose about 100 points (plus commission) before he reaches the $400 minimum account he needs to trade. If he loses indeed 100 points he should ask himself if trading is a good decision. and at that point he only lost $600 in total.
If he has a job to pay the bills, he can continue this Ninjatrader experiment for a long time as he has only his losses to pay, no datafeed or anything ealse (except of course commission). That's the cheapest solution.
When I see the statements he posts, I arrive to the following conclusions (based on data that is sometimes confusing and maybe not correct because of that confusion):
First attempt:
he made in 12 trading day $396.13 net profit (after commissions) in 253 contracts. So that's $1.57 per contract, close to zero, and confirms that his system does not work at all.
Second attempt:
he made in 35 trading day $2762.04 net profit (after commissions) in 560 contracts. So that's $4.93 per contract, close to zero, and confirms that his system does not work at all.
Third attempt:
he made in 22 trading day $4,862.6 net profit (after commissions) in 1,294 contracts. So that's $4.52 per contract, close to zero, and confirms that his system does not work at all.
It is not clear which contracts he traded, ES or MES, so I have to show the real results if trading:
- ES: 2,170 contracts in total for $8,020.83 ,net profits. At $50 per point that means he made average $3.696, or 0.07 points per contract. That is basically ZERO.
- MES: 2,170 contracts in total for $8,020.83 ,net profits. At $5 per point that means he made average $3.696, or 0.75 points per contract. That is basically ZERO.