High probability strategies appear "better" because they satisfy
"the need to be right." The other side of the "high probability" coin is "low reward, high risk"; one is an inevitable consequence of the other.
The analogy that sums it up best is "eats like a bird but shits like an elephant."
I went through the same phase where I preferred high probability setups. I've gradually moved over to high reward/risk trades. For me, it's much easier to take small losses and have more opportunities for the high reward.