Quote from Baron:
My electronic scale usually says I'm between 19% and 21% bodyfat. I think it's either screwed up, or I have a lot more bodyfat than I realize.
Those scales are not a very good measure at all. I've had readings from 14% at my gym to 22% on one at a retail store, all in the same week.
People who are "denser", i.e. solid bone structure with more muscle will tend to throw those scales off towards the high end.
A good body fat measure needs to take into account your bone structure and muscle mass. Here is one I've found to be fairly accurate:
http://www.healthcentral.com/cholesterol/home-body-fat-test-2774-143.html
This one puts me right at 15.5% which I think is accurate. I'm 192 and 6'1" and exercise a lot (lots of surfing and cardio, 30 hours + a week combined).
My body fat could be lower given how much I exercise, *however*, my vice is beer. I love beer and that's a lot of extra calories in a week.
With respect to diet; I think anything that limits calories to a reasonable number will work, as long as one can stick to it. That's the real trick; its doing something that you can actually stick to. If you don't like steak and veggies, then you're not going to stick to that diet over the long term...
I don't think its of any use to deprive yourself of the foods you like, just moderate a bit and do regular exercise.
Mike