Matcha's Dow E-mini Journal

Quote from jokepie:

Matcha,

This is the key message here !!

Very well stated by KDASFTG ..

Find HAPPYNESS in the process, dont hate/ or fill ur mind with negative thoughts of being a looser on a down day and Do not get over joyed when you have a home run.
Understand that its the Clarity of thoughts gained via experience and understand of your purpose will free you.

Some time you have to learn this on your own, it take a while. I was not fortunate like you to have some good Folks like KDASFTG try to pry your eyes open.

Its hard to move your focus from results to the process, just as KDASFTG mentioned, our society has alot to with it.

Gudluck !

Agree!
yes. I feel very fortunate and grateful. Keep writing this journal has a huge impact on my learning curve. All these mental problems should be recognized sooner than later.... and thanks to SIM.
No matter how hard this is, this is the path I choose. I will do whatever it takes.
 
Quote from Snowman75:

...
I think this is the most difficult part in trading. You need to be able to shift from the emotional rollercoaster to accepting the losses as a normal part of business. So so so hard. Whenever you feel you have gone past it. Boom you're at it again. But Master is so right. You have your business plan. You've seen it work. You need to manage those losses and not let it bug you and move on. Personally, I feel I am almost there and I've been trying to get my daytrading to work for a few years now.

Most of the time I was in rollercoaster land and whenever I was down I would start tweaking my methods, indicators, etc. Instead needed to stick to 1 method and make it work. It took a few years to get it. Now 1 method and making it work. You already have it. Stick with it and work on the emotional side. As Elder says Mind, Method, Money Management. You have 2 and 3. Now you need 1.

Regarding yty's trades I really don't like the first long. If you want something additional to look at for big picture, then check out Market Profile. Below is the DIA (ETF for Dow).

Market slammed through the previous POC (shown by line) on strong volume. If anything that pullback was a short. Market went strongly down into the value area of 2 days ago and paused at around the POC. Coincidence? Not in my book. You took a long which personally I liked but didn't work. So be it. The market then continued down and you took a short which I also love as it takes advantage of the failure of price to find support at an area considered value. But you were shaken out. I'm not sure about your entry/exit but prob should have given it more time. The strong volume pushing down was a good indication that some followthrough would occur.

Anyway, my 2 cents. Good luck today!

Thank you ,Snowman. I especially like the quote from Mr. Elder.

Yesterday I wasn't focused enough. I got very emotional.
the first long in my mind is still OK. But was lack of experience to reverse the trade when it's failed since it bears sees this as a L/H after it broke the TL and short it aggressively. IMHO, Usually price hugging at EMA with bears an bulls are almost equal strong, this is always the fighting area. its also the confluence of the POC area and magnetic price area. ALways be ready here to join the winners. But got to do it fast.

The long at 10am is a mistake that I have eliminated it from my Trading plan. It was technically a 3 pushes down wedge reversal pullback setup.Its at the confluence zone of the S/R and MM down. I took this in a wrong market context. Its a hard sell bear day. And the signal bar of the reversal is very weak.

here is what I learned about the similar set up.
today we had the 3 pushes micro wedge down at 9:00. Price broke the bear TL and made HH at 8:00. so the 9:15 wedge pullback has a bit better odds to succeed. Its a potential HL. And the 5 min signal bar is very strong. And also there was a bear trap. So today it would be a right market context to take the same setup. I only took the trade on paper since I had the rule from YTD not to take the early pullback.

I am glad I learned something.:p
 
Quote from Matcha:

Stayed very calm today......

PnL: $70, 15pts. 2 trades.

Hi Matcha,

It's cool to stay calm. :)

You did well today for taking only LONG trades after a PB in the first 1.5 hours.

I believe at the end of the day, when you look back, you will be at peace with yourself when all your trades follow your planned setup. Win, loss or b/e (like all the Maters said), you know you are training yourself to have the DISCIPLINE to follow your plan and not be distracted by previous trades!

Remember, to keep things simple like Master RN said.

--po
P.S. I made 2 long trades at the same pullback areas similar to your 2 trades. Net +1.0 ES points. Then back to my mental trading exercise for the rest of the day. I am seeing more potential setups now than before.
 
Quote from KDASFTG:

Matcha,

In time, you will also come to realize, that this really is a, pattern recognition numbers game,…..THAT YOU NOW OWN!



KDASFTG


Very Nice post :)

RN
 
Quote from KDASFTG:

Matcha,

“Much Learning Does Not Teach Understanding”.

I think your wheels are still on the rails, so to speak, but I believe you are about to take a non-useful sidetrack from your objective of disciplined trading. But before you move any further down this path, at this time I feel it is my obligation to redirect you. Your choice is to accept or reject, and I'm at peace with either decision.

Matcha please excuse me but like Redneck, I'm going to be frank and candid, and you need to fully comprehend and understand what I’m about to say: You have only just begun to learn about trading and the trader’s mindset. These concepts are still very much new to you. You are still very much a “babe in the woods” with learning these skills and techniques. And further, right now it doesn’t even occur to you that some of us out here in the ether of cyberspace have been working for decades to earn the skills we ever so politely share with you. But as the saying goes; “What you gain too easily, you esteem too lightly”.

And, I can see by reading your comments over the last few days that, your “expectations” about where you think you are, and the reality of where you really are, are pretty much out of line. As MD says in his book, “there is nothing more painful than an unmet expectation”. You unwittingly bear witness to this regularly now. This is because, I do think that you believe that, since you’ve diligently “paid your dues” by picking up some new dynamic techniques, or reading MD once or twice, that you now, fully understand the technique, or see exactly what MD is talking about with this “thinking in probabilities” concept. This is understandable, you have been working hard. Well sorry, but I’m here to tell you that you still have not as yet learned the lessons.

* Seeing the lesson is good, but it doesn’t mean that you know it.

* Knowing the lesson is better, but it doesn’t mean that you understand it.

* Understanding the lesson is infinitely better than knowing, but it doesn’t mean you own it.

* Matcha, its only when you OWN IT, that you can BELIEVE IT,...... at a level where you can CONSISTENTLY ACT ON IT.

You see, much learning does not teach understanding, but you must learn that understanding is only just the beginning of real learning.

As I read your words, I watch as you set yourself up for your daily emotional rollercoaster ride. And, I can’t help but wonder, what kind of inappropriate beliefs are you now inculcating with this last ride. What kinds of mental damage are you now imposing on your belief system and trading psyche?

I can see that right now, you are no longer in control of your “state of mind” while trading. The market has more or less control over you, and over your state of mind while you are trading. This is because the results of your last few trade(s) unwittingly dictate and determine your current state of mind. I can see it in your writing.

If you have a winning day, you’re on cloud nine. Even to the point of offering your help to the poor unfortunates who don’t as yet have your level of achievement. But, by the same token, if you have a losing day, then its “what have I done wrong now”, "back to the drawing board", "oh when will this frustration ever end". Somebody out there in cyberspace,….help.

Please excuse my candor in the last few paragraphs, but I had to say these things. Now, on to resolving some problems. First, lets define one particularly recurring problem: This problem is that you are so overly concerned with the RESULTS of your trading, that you totally ignore the “PROCESS” of your trading. At this stage of your development, your primary objective is LEARNING the appropriate SKILL SETS necessary to succeed.

At this point in your development, who gives a tinkers damn about whether or not you made a nickel or dime today in Sim or Live, but thank God you had the good sense to be in Sim. However, the real issue for you is; what skill sets or techniques did you exercise, practice, or hone today, and how well did that process go? You must move your current focus from the "win/lose" results of your trading, to the process of your trading. Profits are the “by-product” of the “process”.

When your focus is the process, it changes things for the better. You will see more in your charts, you will understand more from your charts, you will be at one with your charts. With nothing to fear from your charts anymore, because fear is not your focus, they will begin to speak to you with clarity and purpose.

In the society we have built, we all have an ingrained fear of being wrong. Our society is built to punish those who get it wrong. However, in the trading world, we understand that being wrong and losses are an essential part of the "success process". Our world is different from the outside world. We need to think different from the outside world, and sometimes our ideas are diametrically opposed in our market environment. This is now your world. You learn to accept being wrong, as being ok, and to manage trading losses, as you would business inventory.

More importantly, you must mentally move your Center of Focus. When your Center of Focus in trading is to learn, practice, or hone a skill, who among us is afraid to learn, practice, or hone a skill? This is the “mindset” you enter into as your trading day begins. Your thoughts as you begin the day are that; “Today I will get the opportunity to exercise my skills again”. With that kind of attitude going into your day, you start off with a very real sense of "Power and Control".

This is because you do in fact have the Power and Control. When your focus is the process, surprisingly, you will experience very few “emotionally down days” from your trading. This is because you are not riding an emotional rollercoaster anymore with "win/lose" up and down results. You will gain a lasting sense of control over your trading that will stay with you for many profitable years to come.

In time, you will also come to realize, that this really is a, pattern recognition numbers game,…..THAT YOU NOW OWN!

Now Matchhopper,……go get to work on that!

Master K

“crass dismissed”
Wow. This is probably the best trading-related thing I've read on the internet. Thank you.
 
Quote from Matcha:

Hi, Master K!
I like this name. We now have Master K, Master Boli. Master Nodoji, Master WF, Master RN etc....

Matcha,

I appreciate the consideration – but let’s keep it real

I am simply a dumbass redneck trader

If a master of anything – then let it be a master of that


Please

RN
 
Large gap open today. Possible a gap-n-go day. To trade a day like this at the open. I have learned that from the past I have to act very fast. I don’t like to get in too late then chop myself to death.

So today I refer to the 2 min chart. I entered minor pullback after the first 5 min bar was closed. Then I looked at 5 min. it’s really not necessary to enter on 2min. 5 min also have a inside bar pullback setup on bar2.
Trade 1: 6:35. long +29tk, Took the trade out when see large topping tail and no FT. +29tk

Trade 2. 8:02 Long. Break out Pullback. I took the trade out when I saw topping tail was forming on the entry bar signals a false breakout. B/E

Then market started to do its overlapping thing. But it quietly formed HH and HLs.-a nice bull trending day is continuing.

Trade 3: 10:35 long. Market has finished the 3 pushes up Wedge after spike at the open. Could be a possible wedge top on 5 min chart. But the wedge is very weak and it could be just a continuation of the move up. Here is why today 15 min saved me from the temptation to take shorts. On 15 min chart, no signs of any topping signal. I entered a 2 leg pullback long/failed L2 + false break out set up. Set my target at +10pts.HOD. But when I see the bars started to form a possible reversal signal and thought about the trap time at 10:30-11:00, I took the trade out. In hindsight, the correct trade management should be moving stops to below 10:55 bull trend bar. If it were triggered, then I am wrong. The LH here will be valid. In this case, this LH did not succeed; instead, it broke to the upside nicely. +2tk.

There was also a 2 leg pullback long+a failed BO set up at 8:40. The inside signal bar did not look quite nice to me, so I did not take it. But in hindsight, the low of the bear breakout bar did not even touch the EMA. The low of the pullback reached the 61% of the large breakout bar @7:45. It’s a good setup in trend day. Trend day’s signal bars never look quite right. I will need to do more backtesting on this type of “not so good looking signal bar but valid setups” trade. If I have more than 3 reasons to take the trade, I should.

PnL: 32pts, 3trades (will only include points from today)

attachment.php
 

Attachments

Quote from Matcha:

.....

PnL: 32pts, 3trades (will only include points from today)


Hi Matcha,

Congrats on a job well done! It's great to stay with the trend & most importantly to stick to your plan today!

I took a couple of long trades at a PB. Made a couple of ES pts.

--po
 
Quote from Matcha:

attachment.php
[/B]

M:

You had asked about the matter of multiple time-frames. I want to show you something. Just use your YM trades today 3/3/11 as an example.

Backdrop: today was a big bullish day. Rapid up in the morning and stayed green all day. Not much to do except to long the drops.

I have a composite chart in TradeStation:

YM 1-minute
YM 5-minute
YM 10-minute

3 different time-frames overlaid on the same chart. For simplicity, I had minimized the price bars of the 5-min and 10-min portion. I only retained the momentum indicator portion (called "Vol With Direction"... it is a proprietary momentum indicator that I bought). So what you see is the momentum indicator on 1-minute bars, on 5-minute bars and on 10-minute bars.

On a day like this: Lean on the bullishness (green) of the mid time-frame (5min) and long time-frame (10min). So what you look for are those "bearish" moments in the short time-frame (1min). The most "bearish" moments. They are the bars in the negative quadrant. Especially the second humps (the second mouse). Momentum Divergence. Lean on the MT and LT bullishness, fade the ST bearishness. That's what it meant by multiple time-frame trading.

The vertical lines were opportunity moments. Looks like you had taken some of them.

Now what's RISKY to do: are the up spike bars: where all 3 time-frames ST MT LT are all very green. There is a good chance that price will pull back at those points. (Illustrated by 3 yellow rectangles) If you long at those points, you probably are going to frustrate yourself to see prices turn after you have bought them.

attachment.php
 

Attachments

Back
Top