Quote from ProfLogic:
I agree that volume by iself is worthless or using volume as a separate indicator on a chart is just mildly worthless (some use it effectively). I'm talking about consruting a chart using volume bars exclusively. Huge difference.
Quote from Lojanica:
Start by using volume to screen which markets have the most activity. Increasing volume on a daily, weekly, and monthly basis. That's where the money flow is. See if the price is going up or down. Join the trend at a good entry.
Money flows to different markets based on macroeconomic trends which are the most profitable.
Real Estate ten years ago. Oil 4 years ago.
Equities the past few years---short, then long.
How can volume not help?
For instance Natural Gas has had a serious contraction in net trading volume. It had been serious sell on volume and then over the past 2 years volume has been slowly drying up. We will bottom for sometime and when the volume starts flowing again into the market BAM!!!
Each volume bar will take a variable amount of time to complete, correct? How does that eliminate the variable aspect of time? Unless you mean time isn't a factor because your charts don't include time.Quote from ProfLogic:
I've found the only way to construct a chart naturally is to use volume bar charts because they eliminate the variable aspect of time.
strength.
Quote from Gubinec:
Maybe you're right, I never looked at a volume-bar chart.
What platform do you use or would recommend for volume-bar chart?
Could you please post a volume-bar ES chart of Friday (or any day last week) for comparison purposes?
I'm curious!
Quote from Bullverine:
Ladies and Gentlemen:
I was wondering if anyone could share the market cycles that they have observed and learned from their own experience. Things that seem to happen same time every year/month (example: option expire same time every year or things seem to always go up/down before the X holiday) . Its possible that this might have nothing to do with experience and is public knowledge which I am not aware of, but I would appreciate if someone could shed some light on this.![]()
Quote from trendo:
Each volume bar will take a variable amount of time to complete, correct? How does that eliminate the variable aspect of time? Unless you mean time isn't a factor because your charts don't include time.
Quote from Gubinec:
Thanks for the demo Prof!
Well, the price action looks MUCH more smoother is much more trendy without that noise! That's its biggest advantage, definitely, and one that kills the time charts.
I'll def give it a try. Thanks again!
What would you say about Investor RT?
http://www.linnsoft.com/tutorials/periodicities.htm