The dividend discount model does not fundamentally work because the terminal value continues exist in perpetuity. So the stocks of companies that pay dividends will reflate as they earn for the next dividend.
I think I see what you are trying to say, but that does not discount the other guy's point that paying 5 cents per share out of capital, leaving the company with 25 cents of capital per share, is much less intuitively an "income" event than is collecting and keeping 5 cents per share on an option premium - the first leaves the company with 25 cents capital, the second 30 cents. That's all I'm going to say on that.

