Not many guys I know at this firm pay much attention to this site. Basically Madison is a corporate partner of Generic. Yes the commision rate is high $.01 a share. However the deal is truely proprietary, meaning no money down.
As for being watched like a hawk by the risk management team, if you lose more than $100 in a day trading a 100 shares of any NYSE stock than you should be shut down for the day. Firm loyalty is pretty huge there. Thats why no one says much about the ticket prices. You leave, you don't ever come back, and from what I understand, 90% of those who have left have tried to come back at some point. Its a team atmosphere where people share ideas so that everyone can succeed.