Not sure whether it's the voice over chat or just the quality of the people in the room. To your point, if you don't have quality people in the room who contribute something of value to it, the chat room (voice or chat) can feel like noise. I eventually set-up a room on EchoFin but have limited membership to people I know. Even so, only a handful of folks are active, but for those who are, it's a huge benefit. The biggest benefit for me is I have a place to get my ideas out of my head so even when no one else is engaged, I post my ideas. As you know, the reality is that most people are only "interested" in making money trading but very few are "committed."