Looking for a mentor

Quote from NoDoji:



What percentage of aspiring traders do the hard work first? I don't know the numbers on that, but I know that out of a few dozen ET-ers with whom I've had detailed conversations, only a couple had a detailed trading plan and followed it (they were both consistently profitable).



that's the same for most things in life, ND. How many can make the sacrifices and do the hard work needed. They think others who "made it" got there by immaculate perception.
 
To ND

It is clear from what I see that indicators are forming a divergence ,and it is also clear that we'll have an additional up move 80-100 points approx.before this divergence establishes.

You can by from the current levels ~~1235-50 and hold up to ~~1330-50 where the divergence will trigger,and correction will follow.

I'm sorry I don't use stop losses and don't set profit targets.

Don't worry about daytrading so far it will take about a week and a half for this scenario.
 
Quote from Alcoeus:

I'd recommend Trading and Exchanges Market Microstructure by Larry Harris for a good understanding of the inner workings of the markets.

B]


great recommendation

I strongly suggest to the OP that they read the Harris book stat... gotta learn the basics first and develop a solid, general understanding; in med school they don't teach surgery first; they teach anatomy + basic biochemistry
 
Quote from sivachevy:

To leapup:

Haha love that comment but what you do not know is I was born in Brooklyn. So where does that leave me?? i DONT KNOW. BUt i love all styles of pizza. Never tried new haven pizza though, however I have tried sicilian, new york, deep dish from pizanos is the best in chi-town, and buddy's from motown.

Lol! Welcome to the pizza 12 step program! No, this program isn't 12 steps to get you to stop eating pizza, but 12 steps to getting the best pizza you can!:)

And if you're fromm Brooklyn, no doubt you're probably a member of the club whether or not you even knew it. Lol!

Last, I made the dough yesterday, and made four 18" pies this evening as my Sons wanted their High School buddies to watch football here and KNOW that I make the best pizza's around. Gotta say, I'm good when it comes to making these works of art!:cool:

Youz shoulda been here. It was beautiful! Fughet about it.:D
 
Quote from traderslair:

I don't agree with the books on Al Brooks. They are hugely overrated. I even don't think Al Brooks is a profitable trader.

I DISAGREE.

There is only 1 way to become a profitable trader: Blow up several accounts, cry, feel pain, urge to give up 10x, the ones who overcome become profitable. The others fail.

I DISAGREE. MANY TRADERS HAVE STARTED, LOST A LITTLE AT TIMES, BUT NEVER BLEW OUT THEIR FIRST ACCOUNT, GOING ON TO BECOME VERY WEALTHY PEOPLE. I WILL SAY THAT I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO GET ACROSS ABOUT LOSS BEING A FORM OF "TUITION" THOUGH. WHEN I'VE LOST $, I LEARNED WHY, AND CONSIDERED IT (AND STILL DO), TUITION. HOWEVER, I DON'T HARP ON THE LOSS, AS THAT IS AN EMOTIONAL BLOCK THAT ABSOLUTELY WILL KILL A PERSON AS A TRADER.

There is practical no profitable trader who never faced the above items.

YOU NEED TO ELABORATE ON THE "ABOVE ITEMS" YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT.

There is no shortcut, even not if you're a millionaire.

I AGREE.

Without enough cash on your hands don't even start. Get a job, enjoy your life.

PROBABLY TRUE, BUT THERE WERE OTHERS WHO MADE A FEW GRAND INTO A FEW MILLION, AND I FIRMLY BELIEVE THAT A PERSON WITH THE FIRE, AND DESIRE WILL EMERGE UN-BURNED IN THE LONG RUN.
 
Quote from pepdegree:

To ND

It is clear from what I see that indicators are forming a divergence ,and it is also clear that we'll have an additional up move 80-100 points approx.before this divergence establishes.

You can by from the current levels ~~1235-50 and hold up to ~~1330-50 where the divergence will trigger,and correction will follow.

I'm sorry I don't use stop losses and don't set profit targets.

Don't worry about daytrading so far it will take about a week and a half for this scenario.

If I buy here at, say, 1250-ish and I have no stop loss in place and tomorrow morning the market is gapped down to 1150, what is the plan?

I mean if you have an indicator (or set of them) that leads price just as it's about to take off, why not place a stop loss just below the S/R level off which it's about to run?

What I like about price action trading is I'm swept into a position in the direction price is moving, and I can use tight stops. I accept nothing less than a minimum profit target (unless a stop-and-reverse setup appears), and my minimum target averages out to 1.8 times my average loss. Often the minimum profit target is exceeded significantly (in a strong trend or a strong consolidation breakout).

If your indicators can possibly lead price, I see no reason not to limit risk by placing a stop loss.

Right now the ES is at a level of equilibrium. It needs to break through Friday's high with conviction before further upside is indicated; otherwise a pullback is in order with the support levels of 1223, 1218, 1190 and 1170 all in line to be tested during the pullback phase.
 
If I buy here at, say, 1250-ish and I have no stop loss in place and tomorrow morning the market is gapped down to 1150, what is the plan?_

it could happen at this price level,at any price level actually,but what is the structure of the divergence anyway?the recent peak is always higher then the previous peak,right?we have a peak now,we will have a higher peak then that.you can by at the current level for sure,use double-tripple margin,use march contracts to be more comfortable.

I mean if you have an indicator (or set of them) that leads price just as it's about to take off, why not place a stop loss just below the S/R level off which it's about to run?

it doesn`t make any sense!

What I like about price action trading is I'm swept into a position in the direction price is moving, and I can use tight stops. I accept nothing less than a minimum profit target (unless a stop-and-reverse setup appears), and my minimum target averages out to 1.8 times my average loss. Often the minimum profit target is exceeded significantly (in a strong trend or a strong consolidation breakout).

that is true for local trading,but it`s not my game as i found it very intense and energy consuming for myself,i allow it to drawdown.but you still don`t have to use stop losses.play one side only.

If your indicators can possibly lead price, I see no reason not to limit risk by placing a stop loss.

you contradict yourself here

Right now the ES is at a level of equilibrium. It needs to break through Friday's high with conviction before further upside is indicated; otherwise a pullback is in order with the support levels of 1223, 1218, 1190 and 1170 all in line to be tested during the pullback phase.

you`ve missed a lot.use GPS instead of traffic signs.
 
Quote from jack hershey:

From personal experience, I disagree with you.

The shortcut, for me was systematically (and unknowlingly at the time) building my mind as I made profits.

I am much older than William J. O;Niel but we did have the same essential initial experience. So did Darvas, a contemporary of mine.

You got to your views in the absence of having to work on learning about how markets work.

The three of us that I mentioned did not follow your path in any way whatsoever.

What was our common bridge? The bridge is my symbol as it turns out.

We all took the came shortcut bridge.

In modern times, this shortcut is being explained very thoroughly in the field of neuroscience. I am so glad this confirmation has finally appeared.

Look back into your past and find out what you missed doing to have employed the shortcut.

It is a simple fact that you did not do purposeful drills.

The only reason I did was, in fact ,serendipity. for me I had to do sharts by had on a blank chart I inked on vellum and copied as brownlines using a freee blueprint machine. I habded out brownlines of my plots so others could take over the plotting as we build our three Beta Universe of active stocks to trade.

So you did it the CW way. And you mind is still not differeniated at all. Too bad. Drills create inference. The mind ordganizes the inference into a differiated spectrum. as the spectrum forms, the mind raises questions requiring drills to answer. finally a simple set of finite sets is built where there is a one to one correspondence of elements form finite set to finite set. It is a system just like reading and arithmatic and driving a car or skiing of playing tennis are mental systems of finite sets. you have some of those BUT you messed up the opportunity to build your mind and now the oppotunity has been withdrawn because of the clutter you continue to struggle in.

test yourself to find out this is true in your case. just go in the market and examine your emotions. for you, having learned failure, your emotions are anxiety, fear and anger. For me and O'Niel and Davas, our emotion set is support, comfort and confidence. In fact, if I feel a tinge of your emotiion set, then I know I do not know at that moment. I journal the time of the moment and review my logic in order to add, if necessary, a sub fractal nuance. this process plays out as iterative refinement of my mind and the logic of trading using just one pattern.

That's all nicely written but the problem with people is that when they start with trading, everybody wants profits FAST.

Why wait? Market is there, look! Just a setup that could have given me money!! Why didn't I take it!!

There is almost no one on this planet that has the power to wait and sim trade like a real trader and do exactly the same when he moves onto real trading.

Maybe in the old days with pen and paper, but nowadays it's impossible to jump in with a live account and make consistent money just like that. I know what beginning or losing traders do and I take profit out of this. You need to sim for several months and create extreme discipline. That takes time and pain.

I don't buy it that 'many' traders started without ever blowing up with a small account and traded that small account into a multi million $ account. That's a pipe dream.

I'm here to tell you: if you haven't started: don't start. If you started: it's a painful ride. Odds are you won't succeed. There are plenty of other very much easier ways to become rich on this planet. Trading isn't one of them.

I'll take anybody up for the test, if you say you just did it without blowing up and are consistent making money I want to see this. I do it now, trading is my primary source of income but I have had my pain and blow ups. I'll show you my account, you show me yours, we can audit it by somebody neutral by both parties accepted.
 
Quote from traderslair:

That's all nicely written but the problem with people is that when they start with trading, everybody wants profits FAST. ''''' GREED'''''''

Why wait? Market is there, look! Just a setup that could have given me money!! Why didn't I take it!! '''''''GREED''''''

There is almost no one on this planet that has the power to wait and sim trade like a real trader and do exactly the same when he moves onto real trading.'''''''''' EVERY OTHER PROFESSION.DO YOUR MENIAL JOB,GET BETTER,PROMOTED TO THE NEXT MENIAL TASK..ETC''''''''

I don't buy it that 'many' traders started without ever blowing up with a small account and traded that small account into a multi million $ account. That's a pipe dream. ''''''''''.REGARDLESS OF THE SIZE,FEW LIVE OUT THE PIPEDREAM,MAILCLERK TO OWNER,,ANY PROFESSION''''''''''
.
this carrot of getting rich quick is just a carrot,like the mule at the plow, most don't figure it out,this profession feeds on greed,other than crime,i think it's in a small percentage of professions that feed on it..actually all get rich quick schemes work the same way,the very few are the bait for the masses ..if you come to this conclusion first,you won't blow out 5 accts,how many get past the carrot and trade this way in the beginning,how many people go to vegas on vacation and gamble his way,they bring 2 k,5k, and plan to limit their loss to that,they plan to lose,for the record i'm in the 5 accts category
 
Back
Top