That's the problems with traders. Most of traders (including myself) find their own strategy the best. If they lose, it's because of market conditions or the broker or market makers or Greenspan .... I don't know about the other sites but I do know that longbull.com is great for new traders who just entered the market. My wife uses it and has made profit. She has never traded before signing up with longbull and doesn't know the difference between marubuzu and doji candlesticks. She does make money by buying and selling according to the recommendations. I tried many times to teach her Moving Averages and Stochastics but she doesn't really care. I have to admit that they know how the market moves and pay a lot of attention to technical indicators indicating trend reversal. I assume they monitor constantly the TRIN, TICK, and Volatility index. I am a gap trader so I dont use their strategy but I am glad that my wife is making money instead of emptying my IB account