Quote from FishSauce:
"The problem comes from puts on dividend paying stocks being expensive enough that selling calls can't offset the difference and you lose the benefit of the dividend."
Can you explain what you are talking about? What do you mean by "expensive"? Volatility are the driving force behind option pricing - in the long run, the valuation of calls and puts would be roughly be a fair value. I dont see how "expensive" put would affect the premium on calls?? ...
{(added with edit)FishSuace, you do understand that Aphie wanted to protect his stock meaning the purchase of puts (I assume). The selling of calls alone adds a cushion against price decline but not protection against large down move. }
The problem is that dividends are also part of the pricing structure. This leads puts to cost more- you pay for the protection of your dividends. The cost of not holding the stock is higher as you do not benefit from the dividend which makes the calls cheaper. Try it out on some high yielding stocks. You will find your yield reduced to between 1-3% max no matter what the dividend of the stock.