I tend to agree with your point.
Additional points:
1. NMR measurement of the NUMBER of LDL particles (not just their size or density) is the cutting edge of lipidology. Some research shows that, compared to old-school blood tests, the particle counts of the various LDL species have a greater correlation with the occurrence of atherosclerosis.
2. I am seeing some disturbing studies where there is no MORTALITY benefit of taking statins (even if there is an amelioration of cardiovascular disease); people die of other things. It is believable on a simplistic level (thats me, simple) because cholesterol is a key macromolecule in human physiology that serves important functions.
3. The basic issue is that the cause of atherosclerosis is unknown; there is circumstantial evidence that cholesterol is involved. But the mechanisms remain mysterious. People with "normal" blood panels do die of cardiovascular disease.
4. So while I am informing an MD about theses points, I usually then mention that eating a lot of fat is much less risky than eating a lot of carbs. If I want to make a new friend, I go on about my opinion that the low-fat mantra that has been pushed for years is probably responsible for the current diabetes epidemic and ineffective in touching cardiovascular disease. Then we are off to the races.....
GK Kid, I agree that a lot of what I read shows the link between fat/cholesterol and heart disease is extremely loose but I have seen plenty of links between high carb consumption/triglycerides and heart disease. I also read too much about what the statins do and as I said the best analogy is chopping the whole tree down to fix a branch.
I am also glad my doctor is also not a fan of statins except in specific high risk cases.
What I find amazing is that people don't realize that doctors don't do detailed studies themselves. A salesman comes with the research and FDA approval and promotes the product for their company (Pfizer, Merck,etc..) and the bullshit studies are used to justify it. Many doctors simply prescribe rather than look at the natural way to reverse the problem if it exists.