Have Moderna or Pfizer published their stats with the Brazilian or S.African strains? All I’ve heard is they may not be as effective and they were working on a booster shot for future strains.Seeing that a 50% effectiveness implies a vaccine is useless. A 66% effectiveness is not very good.
The Chinese vaccines claim an effectiveness of 78% but have been found to be only 51% effective in Brazil.
This implies the J&J vaccine is less effective than the highly criticized vaccine coming out of China.
Have Moderna or Pfizer published their stats with the Brazilian or S.African strains? All I’ve heard is they may not be as effective and they were working on a booster shot for future strains.
Both have publishing information on the U.K. and South African strain. Don't know about Brazil.
So, what I am getting at is that a vaccine can come up short or marginal as a single dose vaccine but turn out to be a crackerjack as 2 dose vaccine. Not sure we or they know yet what the efficacy of a 2 dose regimen would be.
Just to shamelessly reply to my own post, I just heard that J and J is in fact doing a study on administering their vaccine as a 2 dose vaccine to see if that boosts the effectivity.
I also, I continue to not join with those who dismiss it as "useless" based on the 66% per cent overall effectivity. The overall effectivity rate - as neurtralizing, immediate knock out, total prevention vaccine was 66% but the overall effectivity in preventing hospitalizations and deaths was 100%. So, as always I caution against the binary stuff where a vaccine is either classified as good or totally useless. Depends on how you define "effective" as we have already overdiscussed many times. Keeping a person from dying even if they get sick is a plenty good thing to do, and is useful, not "useless."
I think Pfizer and Moderna state they are about 50% on the 1st jab. Israelis stats Pfizer came in well below that on 1 shot, something like 33%.
https://news.yahoo.com/israel-warning-single-dose-pfizer-124313138.html
My elderly aunt got the Pfizer in Ireland, her nursing home newsletter said 33 percent for the first. Perhaps that is age adjusted as it can't be as effective in the very elderly.
I don’t want to cast the J&J vaccine on the trash pile. Specially when the storage and shipping protocols are normal vs the mRNA’s.
If a booster can put them up in the 80-90% they have a winner. No one wants to admit it yet, but it’s looking like boosters are coming for Pfizer and Moderna to stay on top of the new emerging strains as well.
I think a lot of folks, hoping not but figured that might be the case.