Latest Broker Ratings...Is A Joke

Quote from FattBurger:

Bottom line is it’s rigged. Every time you see a few negative comments with in 24 hours there is a swarm of new positive comments…without fail every single time.

Do you think these companies are going to pay top dollar to have there advertisement in a prime spot, and then have negative reviews. Trust me it’s all rigged.
More...
I would use a different word than "rigged" but, in essence, I agree with the point. One or 2 dedicated posters can skew the rating either direction pretty heavily. The important thing is all the "negative" reviews are still there. So, it's up to a trader to make up their mind regarding which reviews provide added value and which do not. For instance, I usually just ignore revews that say "everything is tip-top" or "lots of features in the platform" and don't mention any problems or downside.
 
Quote from FattBurger:

Bottom line is it’s rigged. Every time you see a few negative comments with in 24 hours there is a swarm of new positive comments…without fail every single time.

Do you think these companies are going to pay top dollar to have their advertisement in a prime spot, and then have negative reviews. Trust me it’s all rigged.
More...

Let me ask you a question then:

When you post a review, is it your intention to share what you like/don't like about the broker for others to read, or by posting a negative review you hope to influence the overall score for this broker and are now pissed that your vote has been marginalized by the "swarm of positive comments"? It seems the latter, which makes your review rather disingenuous.
 
Quote from cstfx:

Let me ask you a question then:

When you post a review, is it your intention to share what you like/don't like about the broker for others to read, or by posting a negative review you hope to influence the overall score for this broker and are now pissed that your vote has been marginalized by the "swarm of positive comments"? It seems the latter, which makes your review rather disingenuous.
More...

I don't post reviews, its a waste of my time. And for your information I use Interactive Brokers. They are not perfect but I know of no broker who is.

The point is it's so fake. Every negative review is met with new and glowing reviews within 24 hours....FAKE FAKE FAKE
 
You don't post reviews and you ALREADY have a broker who you are happy with. So, why are you getting so emotional? :)

Also why are you checking the reviews every 24 hrs, LoL :D

Quote from FattBurger:

I don't post reviews, its a waste of my time. And for your information I use Interactive Brokers. They are not perfect but I know of no broker who is.

The point is it's so fake. Every negative review is met with new and glowing reviews within 24 hours....FAKE FAKE FAKE
More...
 
Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

You don't post reviews and you ALREADY have a broker who you are happy with. So, why are you getting so emotional? :)

Also why are you checking the reviews every 24 hrs, LoL :D
More...

I don't see happy anywere in my reply. Your like a little girl running around the school yard telling lies, trying to get some attention.

Make an appointment to see a physiatrist and get some help. And stop sending me PMs
 
Still very emotional I see :)

I sent you 1 PM a month ago saying later man after you stomped your tiny feet and told the world that ET is a site for "loosers". You wrote back that I was a little girl.

http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&postid=2705203#post2705203

Maybe YOU should stop getting overly emotional about all these topics? Or, if you say you are going to leave, then just leave :)

Quote from FattBurger:

I don't see happy anywere in my reply. Your like a little girl running around the school yard telling lies, trying to get some attention.

Make an appointment to see a physiatrist and get some help. And stop sending me PMs
More...
 
I think alot of the IB bashing comes from the smaller futures brokers who want to convince people to use them. If newer traders find out they can trade for the same commission and get better fills, then they'll be out of business.

I never have a problem getting filled, and I never have strange occurunces like you get with the smaller futures brokers. For some reason, many believe that the futures brokers are all legit and above board, but that is absoluetly not true.


I started a thread before about futures brokers taking the other side of the trade against you, and was called crazy, so I asked some of the brokers who advertise to say that it wasn't true. Never got one response. They may be obligated to put your trades through the exchange, but that doesn't mean they do.


IB is professional, they have a very big name to protect. They're not going to steal money from anyone, and risking losing their clients.

Plus, their live chat is great if you ever have a problem.
 
Quote from joe4422:

I think alot of the IB bashing comes from the smaller futures brokers who want to convince people to use them. If newer traders find out they can trade for the same commission and get better fills, then they'll be out of business.

I never have a problem getting filled, and I never have strange occurunces like you get with the smaller futures brokers. For some reason, many believe that the futures brokers are all legit and above board, but that is absoluetly not true.


I started a thread before about futures brokers taking the other side of the trade against you, and was called crazy, so I asked some of the brokers who advertise to say that it wasn't true. Never got one response. They may be obligated to put your trades through the exchange, but that doesn't mean they do.

More...

How would these brokers generate customer statements through their FCM's for trades that never went to the exchange. Do they try to pull it off with cash settles/credits somehow? Without proof or evidence, it seems like a pretty ballsy accusation.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top