Well first
I don't get the point of talking about "belief in" indicators....
It aint church...
Indicators offer you psychological comfort. Something to lean on so you don't blow a gasket if a trade goes south, and so you have some idea of when to get the hell out if it goes north...
Also
I wonder if any of you hosers have taken the time to actually learn how Williams indicators work..For instance
Williams "Ultimate Indicator" combines 7, 14 and 28 day momentum indicators into one...This little trick can be applied to any momentum indicator and then you just slap your name on it...
In this instance you just do the calculations for each individual time frame (7,14,28 for instance), then you sum or average the values to get the "composite" figure..
Here's the formula
1. Calc today's buying pressure
Buying pressure is = today's close - the lower of today's low or yesterday's close.
2. Calc today's true range
True range is the greatest of
Today's high - yesterday's low
Today's high - yesterday's close
Yesterday's close - today's low
Sum the daily BP figures over 7, 14 and 28 day periods
Sum the daily True Range figure for the same periods
Divide the BP sums for each of the period by the TR sums for each period
Weight the BP/TR ratios
4 x (bp7/tr7)
2 x (bp14/tr14)
and bp28/tr28 (not weighted)
Now if you are following this, one of the things you "get" is that the most recent 7 days data are used several times in the calc process. So in effect, the 7 day period is more heavily weighted than the other periods...
One of the things you folks could be doing, is learning about the way that some folks are using cycles in trading to develop indicators. Williams indicator is just one example...There are plenty of others some that even add 4 or 5 periods to get a single composite value..
Why you say....what good is it..well the basic idea is that strength of trend can be derived by obtaining a composite figure taken from several smaller periods (Martin Pring for instance)..
Okay you rocket scientists can take it from here...
Steve
I don't get the point of talking about "belief in" indicators....
It aint church...
Indicators offer you psychological comfort. Something to lean on so you don't blow a gasket if a trade goes south, and so you have some idea of when to get the hell out if it goes north...
Also
I wonder if any of you hosers have taken the time to actually learn how Williams indicators work..For instance
Williams "Ultimate Indicator" combines 7, 14 and 28 day momentum indicators into one...This little trick can be applied to any momentum indicator and then you just slap your name on it...
In this instance you just do the calculations for each individual time frame (7,14,28 for instance), then you sum or average the values to get the "composite" figure..
Here's the formula
1. Calc today's buying pressure
Buying pressure is = today's close - the lower of today's low or yesterday's close.
2. Calc today's true range
True range is the greatest of
Today's high - yesterday's low
Today's high - yesterday's close
Yesterday's close - today's low
Sum the daily BP figures over 7, 14 and 28 day periods
Sum the daily True Range figure for the same periods
Divide the BP sums for each of the period by the TR sums for each period
Weight the BP/TR ratios
4 x (bp7/tr7)
2 x (bp14/tr14)
and bp28/tr28 (not weighted)
Now if you are following this, one of the things you "get" is that the most recent 7 days data are used several times in the calc process. So in effect, the 7 day period is more heavily weighted than the other periods...
One of the things you folks could be doing, is learning about the way that some folks are using cycles in trading to develop indicators. Williams indicator is just one example...There are plenty of others some that even add 4 or 5 periods to get a single composite value..
Why you say....what good is it..well the basic idea is that strength of trend can be derived by obtaining a composite figure taken from several smaller periods (Martin Pring for instance)..
Okay you rocket scientists can take it from here...
Steve

