Ketogenic Diet - Personal Experience

I fail to see the attraction of a risk-laden diet that requires medical supervision.

It is risk-laden if you have a medical condition, I don't. I consulted my doctor about it, it is not constantly supervised as I clarified. End of June I will update tests and scans to see.
 
Last edited:
So just avoid the question of whether to sacrifice fat or protein?

I would have thought that with your extensive knowledge on the subject you'd add something more insightful than just eat a lot less cals to lose a lot of weight quickly.
Honestly, I didn't understand what you were asking me, and I still don't. He's on a keto diet loaded with fat so his hormone levels will be fine.
 
Silly claim if you want to keep your muscle.

Any specific reason you are going at 1200cals a day? At that level you will be shredding a lot of muscle.

Well I did not make that claim which is why I insist on continuing to do exercise.

If you have adequate minimum protein to meet your current LBM needs, you will not be shredding a lot of muscle. Plenty of scientific studies that did research to balance protein intake to preserve LBM while pushing the body to burn fat. I don't have the cites anymore.

If I lose 25 lbs of fat and 5 lbs. I can easily work to get that muscle back but I need to lose the fat. I will use the DEXA scans and body fat breakdown to monitor my LBM.
 
I applaud his effort and I do wish him the best. But it shouldn't be an all-or-nothing proposition of trying to undo years of neglect in a matter of weeks or a few months.


This is the misconception. This is not a few weeks to undue years. When I hit my target weight I will transition to more calories made up of proteins, fats and carbs restricted to vegetables. But I will not return to gluten or added sugars. This is a lifestyle change.

All of you are 100% focused on Stage 1.

Let me repeat....STAGE 1
 
I appreciate the comments but you are commenting as though what I am doing now is going to be my diet for the next 40 years. I am making the decision to give up gluten and sugars long-term as I approach my goal. It is not a crash diet because crash diets are short-term fixes and then you abandon it when you get to whatever level you are going for.
 
It's getting in the crashy zone for sure but he's never going to lose fat at a rate he's happy with on a diet over 2,000 calories per day. I mean, 2,400 is his daily maintenance amount so he's got to cut into that pretty hard to lose real fat.


I think the calculation was 2300 or so but on days I work out I add another 100-200cals form the amount I mentioned here, mostly protein.
 
Best of luck, EOC. Please be careful and keep us apprised of your progress.


Thank you and will do. Once I reach target weight I will keep posting on the diet as I transition to maintenance. Then it becomes more borderline Keto/Paleo as net carbs will increase naturally.

There is a lot of disagreement on this approach and it is not for everyone so NOT TRYING TO CONVINCE YOU.
Just sharing my experience and knowledge for those interested. Do what makes you happy but I have researched this pretty extensively and feel comfortable with the path. Energy levels are coming back to really well. Before workout I time the calories/carbs and it is working for me.

Of course...your mileage may vary.
 
Instead of focusing on calories and weight loss you should focus on preserving your muscle while providing enough nutrients for internal processes to function optimally. That means consuming a certain amount of fat and protein each day, the rest you can fill in any way you want with any amount you want based on body composition goals. Unfortunately, this cannot be done at 1200 cals for a person your size.

Regardless, good luck on the journey and keep us posted of progress. I'd be curious to see the difference in LBM between both DEXA scans.

Funny tidbit - my gf is half your size and is currently cutting at 1500cals a day :)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top