Just who are the bad guys in the polygamy case?

Quote from Rearden Metal:



TraderNik: <i>"...accusations surrounding this polygamist cult compound, specifically that girls as young as 14 were forced into marriage, forced into sex, impregnated and then forced to carry the child to term..."</i>

Nik, I think it would help resolve a lot of the confusion here if you could help point us to credible links that support such claims. If there really is clear evidence of human rights abuses to such an extreme degree, I may even change my opinion about this entire story.

It's a religious cult. So right away, they are brainwashing kids - that's a crime right there. In the US it's legal but morally it's abhorrent.
 
Dozens of federal agencies and every two bit police force now have their own SWAT teams, all pumped up and ready to go. It is a huge potential threat to our liberties.

---------------------------

Imo, it is actually safer. It is intimidating and conveys immediate authority. Even a whack job would not have second thoughts about what he is going to do next other than comply.
 
Quote from trendlover:

Sure, consensual underage sex happens all the time in communitys, and often it is teens experimenting. The difference with the polygamist cult of people and the average american teenager is simply the fact that they are groomed at early age to be given to older men for the mens pleasure. These young girls do not know any other way of life. Therefore it becomes normal to them. They are conditioned. They are not given the opportunity to know they do not have to have sex with old men. They are unaware of their own rights as human beings to make their own choices in life. Their life is planned for them...and that life is to be the young sex partner and baby bearer of old men. All for the the benefit of these men to have many young female sex partners. All in the name of god. Its all about controlling women for the benefit of men.

But what about their god-given right to worship? This is America, land of the free, shouldn't they be allowed to live the way they want? So a few teenager girls get repeatedly raped by middle aged paedophiles - but who are we to judge? The property rights of the sect against arbitrary search and seizure surely come first.
 
Quote from trendlover:

Quote from AAAintheBeltway:

Do you deny that innocent poeple have been sent to prison on bogus child molestation charges? Janet Reno made her reputation in Florida by sending some poor innocent guy to prison on made up charges. There were scores of cases in a small town in Washington state. There were the infamous daycare center cases, where children came up with fantastic stories that clearly could not have happened but people were sent to prison anyway. I am as concerned as anyone else about protecting children, but to suggest that there have not been horrible excesses is to deny reality.

As for this case, all I am saying is I haven't seen any real evidence. I have heard a lot of breathless speculation about old men and young girls, but I haven't heard one of the women complain and I haven't seen one piece of evidence that anyone was coerced, etc. That's not to say that such evidence doesn't exist, bSkip navigat


People
Woman describes eescapef from polygamy
She left the same sect that 534 women, children were freed from in Texas
Video





Video

Over 500 taken from Texas compound
April 8: Authorities remove more than 500 women and children from the Texas compound of a polygamist sect. NBC's Don Teague reports.
Today show

By Mike Celizic
TODAYShow.com contributor
updated 11:25 a.m. ET, Tues., April. 8, 2008
A polygamous community in Texas that follows the teaching of The Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints practices pedophilia, torture and child abuse under the guise of a religion, according to a woman who escaped the sect with her eight children five years ago.

gI think itfs a form of pedophilia hiding behind a religion as a protection,h Carolyn Jessop told TODAYfs Matt Lauer from Salt Lake City on Tuesday. gTherefs just a desire to control and manipulate and torture people, and religion is just used as the cover.h

The sect Jessop escaped is the same one in Eldorado, Texas, that was raided on Monday by state police after a 16-year-old girl called authorities to report that she was being abused. The girl reported that other girls as young as 14 were being forced into plural marriages with much older men.

Story continues below «
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
advertisement



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Police removed 401 children and 133 women from the compound on warrants issued by a judge, who deemed them to be under imminent danger of physical abuse.

Jessop said it took enormous courage for the girl to call police, who still arenft sure if she is among those removed from the compound.

gIt would take courage thatfs even beyond what I could comprehend,h she told Lauer. gShe could not run the risk of being caught. She would have just to have gotten to the point where she would rather be dead than to continue living the way she was living. It would have had to have been that extreme for her, because those are literally some of the risks she was taking.h



When Jessop was a member of the sect, it was centered in Colorado City, Ariz., on the Utah border. The 1,700-acre Texas compound was built after she left. The sectfs leader, Warren Jeffs, was sentenced to 10 years in prison last September after being found guilty of two counts of first-degree accomplice rape for sanctioning the forced marriage of a 14-year-old girl to her 19-year-old cousin.

The 40-year-old Jessop was 18 when she was forced to marry Merril Jessop, who is said to have taken over leadership of the sect when Jeffs went to prison. Merril Jessop was 50 at the time of the marriage and had three other wives. She said from what she has heard and read, the sect has become even more restrictive since moving to Texas.

She has written a book about her experience entitled gEscape,h and in it, she talks about being totally cut off from the world and not being allowed to watch television or read newspapers or magazines.

gEverything you did was monitored and controlled and everybody reported on everyone else,h she said. gIt was a police state. You were not allowed to make decisions in your life. I had no power over my life or the lives of my children. It was a terrible way to live.h

The alleged control began in infancy.

gThe method he would use with infants was a form of water torture,h Jessop said of her former husband. gHe would spank the baby until it was screaming out of control, and then he would hold the baby faceup under a tap of running water so it couldnft breathe. He would do this repeatedly. Sometimes, it would go on for an hour, until the baby was so exhausted it couldnft cry anymore. This method he called ebreaking them.fh

To a child, the abuse becomes normal, she said, and resistance becomes unthinkable to most. gWith this level of mind control, itfs something youfre born into and itfs generational. The babies born into this, they donft stand a chance from the beginning,h she said.

What prompted her to leave was what she saw as a threat to her daughter.

gIt was getting worse every year,h she said of the level of control and abuse. gThatfs one of the things for me where I felt so urgent to get out was that my daughter was turning 14, and Warren was resetting the marrying age at that point to 14. This was in 2003.h

She said her husband controlled his wives through their children. gThe way he controlled me was by being violent to my children,h she told Lauer. gIf I did something that he didnft like, my children paid, and they paid a big price. He would hurt them. If he would have been hurting me, I probably would not have conformed. But when you go after a womanfs child, thatfs one thing that will put a woman on her knees quickly.h

The fundamentalist group claims to hold to the original teachings of Joseph Smith, who founded the Mormon religion in rural upstate New York in 1830. It is not recognized by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, which renounced plural marriage in 1904 under pressure from the federal government.

There are a number of fundamentalist branches with compounds in Utah, Arizona, Idaho, Mexico and Texas, according to Jon Krakauerfs book, gUnder the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith.h






Rulon Jeffs founded the sect that Jessop belonged to and built his original compound in Colorado City, Ariz., on the Utah border. On his death, his son, Warren Jeffs, assumed primacy, along with the title of gPresident and Prophet and Revelatorh and the absolute authority that came with the position.

Jeffs was on the FBIfs 10 Most Wanted list when he was captured in August 2006 while driving through Nevada in a Cadillac Escalade. With him were one of his wives and his brother. Police said Jeffs had four computers, 16 cell phones, various disguises and $55,000 in cash.

Those evil jack-booted government stormtroopers, trampling over the rights of these latter day saints. How dare they!
 
Quote from Cutten:

*cough* George W Bush *cough*
Whatever GWB is, everybody in Europe agrees that you guys are his lapdog! :)

(Not that I enjoy teasing our friends the Brits, but you, Cutten, don't sound like a real one...)
 
Quote from Cutten:

But what about their god-given right to worship? This is America, land of the free, shouldn't they be allowed to live the way they want? So a few teenager girls get repeatedly raped by middle aged paedophiles - but who are we to judge? The property rights of the sect against arbitrary search and seizure surely come first.

You are being sarcastic yes? No one is complaining about these people worshipping their god. The fact is they are a cult who keep their young female girls ignorant and sheltered from the world in order to groom them to be only what these men want, sex with many partners and baby makers to keep the future cult alive. They have violated these womens right to education and the right to choose their path in life.
Really, when teenage girls choose to have sex (right or wrong is not the issue) but when they do choose to have sex, it is almost always with a teen boy who is also at the age of desire and curiosity.
 
I do see how they could have taken the children and mothers together, and not caused so much grief to these mothers and children..but perhaps the authoritys thought that the children will not speak of their sect expierence if thier mothers were brainwashed to keep the children quiet about such things. It is very, very sad for the mothers and the children because they don't realize what has happened is to help them. They know no other life, they don't think any crime has been committed against them in their sect.
 
updated 27 minutes ago
SAN ANGELO, Texas - The belief system at a polygamous sect is abusive and teen girls do not resist early marriages because they are trained to be obedient and compliant, an expert testified Friday in a custody hearing for 416 children seized from a secluded ranch.

Many of the women had children when they were minors, some as young as 13, a child welfare worker said earlier in the child custody hearing, one of the largest and most convoluted in U.S. history.

State District Judge Barbara Walther must decide whether the children will remain in state custody. Child welfare officials claim the children were abused or in imminent danger of abuse because the sect encourages girls younger than 18 to marry and have children.

Story continues below ¡ý
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
advertisement

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

An expert on children in cults testified Friday that while the teen girls believed they were marrying out of free choice, it's a choice based on lessons they've had from birth.

"Obedience is a very important element of their belief system," said psychiatrist Bruce Perry, who interviewed three girls seized in the April 3 raid. "Compliance is being godly, it's part of their honoring God."

He also said that many of the adults at the Yearning For Zion Ranch owned by the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints are loving parents and that the boys seemed emotionally healthy when he played with them.

But, he noted, the sect's belief system "is abusive. The culture is very authoritarian."



Child welfare investigator Angie Voss testified Thursday that at least five girls who are younger than 18 are pregnant or have children. Voss said some of the women identified as adults with children may be juveniles, or may have had children when they were younger than 18.

Identifying children and parents has been difficult because members of the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints have given different names and ages at various times, Voss said. The state has asked that DNA be taken from all of the children and their alleged parents to help determine biological connections. The judge has not ruled on that request.

Courtroom turns into circus
The court hearing disintegrated into farce early Thursday, as hundreds of lawyers who descended on San Angelo for the proceedings shouted objections or lined up to cross-examine witnesses. The judge struggled to maintain order.

On Friday, Walther was testier ¡ª and stricter, cutting off prolonged cross-examinations of a witness when a line of 10 defense lawyers had formed to ask essentially the same questions. She solicited objections when she felt questioning was going on too long.

The renegade Mormon sect is led by Warren Jeffs, who is currently awaiting trial in a Kingman, Ariz., jail on charges related to the promotion of underage marriages. He previously was convicted of being an accomplice to the rape of a 14-year-old wed to her cousin in a Utah case.

The sect came to West Texas in 2003, relocating some members from the church's traditional home along the Utah-Arizona state line.
 
Back
Top