- Never said don't back test, can't tell if you're alluding to that I said that or not?
- Markets are fractal so yes same patterns play out on every chart from smallest to largest
I'll just say any serious trader who is looking to make day trading their primary income and is only going to use a strategy that you describe, without adding any additional filter is going to make a hard task even harder. Particularly if we're speaking of actively intra-day trading.
I agree it is not rocket science. Sure you can have a simple strategy that works and if that's all you have and you know it works over time great. Still if you can add a filter in you can reduce draw down periods, which can be an absolutely killer particularly if you don't have large amount of capital. It makes the entry-level to trading a lot more difficult to produce the necessary income to be full time trading (if that's your goal, not saying anyone has to do that).
All I am saying it is foolish to discard a trading system that works, that has been backtested, just because it is experiencing a rough patch. Any trader out there no matter how good, can experience 7 losing trades, one after another. In the same vein, that same trader can win 7 straight trades and think he is invincible and will never lose. No trading system out there is 100% perfect and drawdowns are a natural result of market reactions via pullbacks or going sideways in a trading range. That cannot be avoided. Adding filters can improve or worsen any trading system. Again, you have to backtest it to see how that filter affects that trading system as a whole. It is far better to stick to what already works than, keep changing your trading system trying to squeeze out the last dollar. In most cases, it makes things worst not better.
