You state this as though it is obvious, but it's anything but. There is a fair question of whether or not someone's religion demands adherence to policies inconsistent with our Constitution. Belief in Sharia Law, which is meant to supersede civil law, is clearly problematic.
It's ironic that suddenly religious beliefs are off the table, but your side has no problem judging conservative Christians on their belief system.
Remind me of the 1st commandment again?
.