Java IDE: Eclipse vs. Netbeans

[Member51]

Thanks everyone for the feedback. I though the split might be more or less even, but Eclipse clearly eclipses the competition.

 

[swingtrader123]

The only place where NetBeans out shines Eclipse is in GUI creation. NetBeans has a very good Visual GUI editor.

 

[Algo_Design_Kid]

Quote from TigerBalm:

Eclipse, because of it's Marketplace : a plug-in probably exists for every dev problem you need to tackle. The Marketplace is what has elevated Eclipse to Emacs status; it's like a mini-OS now!

Could you give some examples if you find the time?

 

[GPUalgo]

Quote from Kevin Schmit:

Emacs plus the command line.

The fancier the IDE, the less productive the programmer.

What a troll. emacs has a massive learning curve and the lack of easily usable intellisense doesn't help. Eclipse is one of the most fully featured IDEs and really improves productivity. Not to mention the plugins for group projects. I suspect you code alone

You can't argue the fact that having your syntax errors highlighted instantly isn't a productivity booster.

 

[leveragize]

Excuse me but code completion and error highlighting already help a lot. A "fancy" IDE will also help on navigating and refactoring code.

I think such IDE is a must for any project with an architecture.

I also recommend IntelliJ. They have a community edition with most things you will need. They also sell personal licenses for $199 each.

I am not affiliated with JetBrains, but I have been using IntelliJ since version 4.

 

[jpsubs2k]

I think now with the addition of Window Builder Pro to the open source domain via the purchase of Instantiations by Google the GUI advantages of Netbeans over Eclipse are non existent. Check out this link in case you are not familiar with the tool

http://code.google.com/javadevtools/wbpro/quick_start.html

Enjoy
JP

 

[mikesmithv]

Thanks for posting that. I downloaded Eclipse and Window Builder Pro and it is very good. I switched years ago to Netbeans from Eclipse primarily for the UI builder so I was pleased to see all my past work is read directly by Window Builder Pro. It feels good to get back to Eclipse.

This is the second great programming tip I've read in a month from a trading forum. How times have changed.

 

[TigerBalm]

Quote from Algo_Design_Kid:

Could you give some examples if you find the time?

Sorry for the late reply! I didn't see this reply till today!

I primarily use :
- Subclipse + SVNKit for repository access
- JUnit, though it's now bundled along with Eclipse, so not sure it's even a plug-in any more!
- the Maven plugin m2e
- AnyEdit tools : editing help
- EasyShell to open the file/directory in Windows Explorer with a keyboard shortcut
- Eclipse ColorTheme : so that I can have a more pleasing, dark background instead of white

P.S.
Dear ET owners, why is your forum software so shitty? Instead of "Emails sent to you whenever someone replies to anything in the thread", I'd like, "Emails sent to you only whenever someone replies to me".

 

[mikesmithv]

More on my transition from NetBeans. The Eclipse editor highlighted this obvious error and reported "Null pointer access: The variable td can only be null at this location":

ThrustData td = timeVolData.getThrustData();
if (td == null) {
    newPriceCount = td.getNumTicks();
}

The Netbeans editor error checking missed this one. It has been sitting there a long time, a time bomb ready to go off. Price action would have to be just right for that code to execute - just lucky so far. Netbeans had a plugin call FindBugs but it reported many things that were not errors and when I upgraded NetBeans I couldn't even get it to install, so I just dropped it. Very happy with Eclipse so far.

 

[spacewiz]

FindBugs is a stand alone project, has been developed an widely used for static code analysis an provides a lot of value when used correctly. It is highly tunable, but should not be used by novice or inexpirienced developers.