Quote from ByLoSellHi:
I strongly disagree.
You say it's an emotional argument now.
If you had just one experience where a powerful, aggressive criminal was intent on doing you or one of your loved ones serious bodily harm or death - just one - your idealism would quickly be shattered, as in a nanosecond.
Your idealism would melt instantaneously into realism and pragmatism.
It's a mean world out there. Home invasions happen. Rapes happen. Assaults happen. Murders happen.
Every day.
Nothing is more American in concept and practice than self-empowerment; this is probably why the country is in the mess it is right now, as we're becoming a nanny state, whether Republicans or Democrats are in power at any given time.
We used to be free of government shackles to empower ourselves. We used to be free to make our own decisions, based on our individual desires, so long as those desires were not harmful to others.
We used to be empowered by our government. Now we are shackled by it.
Government in America is not 'by, of and for the people' anymore. Government is a machine that just grows in power and regulatory appetite each successive year, holding out false promises of 'safety' to lure people into giving up self-empowerment, while delivering less and less of anything worthwhile.
So, if the bad man comes into your home late at night, and wants to do you and your family harm, and he is armed well with a sawed off shotgun or .45ACP handgun, do you feel comfortable calling 911 and arming yourself with a bat or crowbar, and riding it out for what could be as long as 20 minutes?
Well, do you?
98% of the time, simply drawing a gun stops a crime in progress. That means if your wife/gf/daughter is about to be raped, and she has a gun and draws it, without doing anything else, she is now 50 times less likely to get raped.
That by itself is enough justification to keep guns legal, even if a few psychos, drug dealers and gangsters wipe more of each other off the face of the planet each year.
Anyone who wants to ban guns is supporting a 50-fold increase in the likelihood of a gun-toting woman to be successfully raped.