Because I don't see how anyone can talk shit about that method lol. Not saying it's guaranteed money (obviously), but seems to be a part of a lot of systems.
Is Scatty Completely Full of Crap About Price TA?
- Thread starter Scataphagos
- Start date
Instead of writing like a professional writer, crappy scatty should post his trade just after he enters the trade.
Then we can track your performance.
Post the chart showing entry price, entry time, the STOP.
Some members might find your TA stuff useful.
Some members like to see the writings from the professional writer.
I find it totally useless, worthless and full of garbage unless you write like a professional trader
You can track how many THUMBS Up you are receiving.
Unfortunately you wouldn't know how many THUMBS DOWN. It could be in thousands.
Without knowing these numbers, you can never ever make progress in your writings
Then we can track your performance.
Post the chart showing entry price, entry time, the STOP.
Some members might find your TA stuff useful.
Some members like to see the writings from the professional writer.
I find it totally useless, worthless and full of garbage unless you write like a professional trader
You can track how many THUMBS Up you are receiving.
Unfortunately you wouldn't know how many THUMBS DOWN. It could be in thousands.
Without knowing these numbers, you can never ever make progress in your writings
Last edited:
Where are the trader's yachts??
Its a serious question. I like all the stuff you show, but putting it together is the hard part. Everyone knows to buy support and sell resistance, but how long do you hold it if its going in your favour? And more importantly, how long to do hold it when its going against you? We want to see someone who has put it all together. Lets see all the wins and losses.
If so many people are thankful because it has made them profitable, surely there would be some journals or PnL statements shared.
Analysis without entries and exits is like a guy who can jerk off in his basement anytime he wants, but does this really mean he can pick up a hot chick and be the best lover she has ever had? I'm not sure all that masturbation in a basement is helpful when it comes to real world interactions.
Of course. It's basic, fundamental chart reading.
As I've said before... "Price TA shows the START... after that, you have to play it by ear". I understand it isn't "everything you'd like to know", but it's a valuable something.
The trouble is that in trading, everything is a valuable something. Even guys who you astrology as an example sometimes it it out of the ballpark. I have also seen guys using cycles do very well sometimes. Fibs guys swear by their levels, but this mean that you're buying at every retracement and then taking credit for the one that turns price.
So unfortunately, I'm not impressed by a valuable something in trading. It needs to be more comprehensive.
So what's the problem?
HINDSIGHT ANALYSIS.
If you wanna be believed, make the call BEFORE it happens.
Before what happens, you ask?!
Before the damn price reverses!
Otherwise, what you say is not a FACT but another after-the-fact BS.
Don't bother. I did that 3 months in advance to the day practically and people here still found something to gripe about.
I don't know what your ta is cuz I think you blocked me but I can tell you that most people here don't have a clue about ta... At best they're doing support resistance, maybe misguided order blocks, Etc.
I know how D must feel when talking about options..its how I feel when talking TA with this crowd.
I love Scat because when he posts, wars errupt.
You guys remember Surf? Surf was like that, but that guy drove me bonkers.
Just my opinion, the S/R stuff Scat posts are very basic TA theory, no rocket science, but no one in their right mind would want to post rocket fuel trading ideas as it would instantly blow it up.
You guys remember Surf? Surf was like that, but that guy drove me bonkers.
Just my opinion, the S/R stuff Scat posts are very basic TA theory, no rocket science, but no one in their right mind would want to post rocket fuel trading ideas as it would instantly blow it up.
