Is price movement really random and unpredictable?

How accurately can you predict the next bar or candle?

  • Total voters
    39
  • Poll closed .
SimpleMeLike said:
Hello rb7,

No we are right on target.

You said, I should not give advice if I am not making money trading right?

So I am asking you VERY simple questions. I will ask again to you:

1. Please provide the link to post(s) on ET forum website where the advice is valuable.

2. Please provide the link to where other ET members are showing proof of making money.

Thank you ,
More...
Sorry, but I don't have time to scan all ET posts to find answers to your questions (so, they aren't rhetorical!).

And btw, how these questions have to do with the fact that your advices are worthless if you aren't profitable?

If you don't know how to cook, don't tell others how to cook.
It's not because you know how to trade that you know how to be profitable.
 
SimpleMeLike said:
Hello rb7,

No we are right on target.

You said, I should not give advice if I am not making money trading right?

So I am asking you VERY simple questions. I will ask again to you:

1. Please provide the link to post(s) on ET forum website where the advice is valuable.

2. Please provide the link to where other ET members are showing proof of making money.

Thank you ,
More...
Dude, the issue with you ain't about advice because the things you proffer as advice are't advice. For example, "Go make money everyday on ES" is NOT an advice (to which I would like to add, "No shit, sherlock!!" :sneaky:). It's just a useless tautology. If you want to add value to this forum, give something more concrete that others can chew on.
 
schizo said:
If you want to add value to this forum, give something more concrete that others can chew on.
More...
Hello schizo,

You claim my post do not add value, please provide the following to me please:

1. Please provide the link to post(s) on ET forum website where the advice is valuable.

Thank you,
 
rb7 said:
Sorry, but I don't have time to scan all ET posts to find answers to your questions (so, they aren't rhetorical!).

And btw, how these questions have to do with the fact that your advices are worthless if you aren't profitable?

If you don't know how to cook, don't tell others how to cook.
It's not because you know how to trade that you know how to be profitable.
More...
Hello rb7,

Well, you said that my post are not valuable sir, so obviously, this mean you seen post on ET forum website that are valuable to your liking right?

You also said I am not a profitable trader, right?

Well, I will ask you for the 3rd time:

1. Please provide the link to post(s) on ET forum website where the advice is valuable.

2. Please provide the link to where other ET members are showing proof of making money.

Thank you ,
 
volpri said:
ROFLMAO old guys.....
More...
Hello Volpri,

LOL, you have to excuse @NoahA.

He has no idea how closed minded he is and literally stuck between his head and his left and right ear.

He can be powerful trader, if he open his mind outside of what he think he knows.
 
SimpleMeLike said:
Hello rb7,

Well, you said that my post are not valuable sir, so obviously, this mean you seen post on ET forum website that are valuable to your liking right?

You also said I am not a profitable trader, right?

Well, I will ask you for the 3rd time:

1. Please provide the link to post(s) on ET forum website where the advice is valuable.

2. Please provide the link to where other ET members are showing proof of making money.

Thank you ,
More...
I've never wrote that your posts were not valuable.
I've never wrote that you were not profitable.

I just wrote that advices to make money are useless if you cannot show proof that you are profitable.

As for your questions, for once, do your homeworks. Stop waiting for the world to get what you want.
 
schizo said:
Dude, the issue with you ain't about advice because the things you proffer as advice are't advice. For example, "Go make money everyday on ES" is NOT an advice (to which I would like to add, "No shit, sherlock!!" :sneaky:). It's just a useless tautology. If you want to add value to this forum, give something more concrete that others can chew on.
More...
Hello schizo,

The advice you provide is no good either. And the coronavirus not real, oh no wait it is real.

I also think Biden is a good president and I also think Trump is a good president. And I think the sky is blue today as well.

LOL, this a trading is forum. Your opinion is NOT worth a penny with hole in it.

LOL, this a trading is forum. My opinion is NOT worth a penny with hole in it.
 
rb7 said:
I just wrote that advices to make money are useless if you cannot show proof that you are profitable.
More...
Hello rb7,

You claim that "advices to make money are useless if you cannot show proof that you are profitable.", correct?

This mean, you know somewhere on ET forum website of advice that is good and with proof of profitability with the advice, ok so please show me this.

If you can not provide what I am asking you for, then you can not say "advices to make money are useless if you cannot show proof that you are profitable."

So For the 4th time,

1. Please provide the link to post(s) on ET forum website where the advice is valuable.

2. Please provide the link to where other ET members are showing proof of making money.

Thank you,
 
I remember being watching VST with great interest back in the day a long time ago trading at Starbucks. His idea of scalps over and over and seeing inside a bar always stuck with me. I just never could learn to program so years later I had to see how I could trade outside of those millisecond HFTs taking thousands of trades a day for a penny or sub penny.

My first idea forscalping in yesteryear was scalping within the spread back in the day. That was fun and profitable. Then they ruined it by going to decimals. So, I had to come up with a way to scalp profitably outside the range of those HFTs. At least outside of the zone where a lot of their action was taking place.

VST is old but he can code. His profit targets are too small for myself but he, I suppose, has coded it up. I cannot think that fast. I have to work in a range of 1 to 8 points.

I would not write off as rubbish what VST says. He may be old but he still has an active mind! And apparently, he still likes coding.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top