TS,
Trading economic #'s is the wrong focus IMO. I trade candlesticks patterns, with S and R and watch the econ number to see how price reacts to my set ups. But I don['t trade around reports, too much volatility, unpredicatable. By no means do I know it, so take it for what it is worth.
Search around and you will see most people whom try to trade the news lose. It sounds to me that is what you are doing.
S and R is good to trade off of along with another confirming indicator whether it be candles, bars, oscillators. I have found 3 indicators/setups works well, more is too much, less is too few.
Another thought, read some books by pro traders, Buzzy Schwartz, etc. I think you will find most of them could not match your "expected" results so early on, so why do you?