As i read your post i recollect stories i heard from few pit traders on LIFFE that i met ages ago.Could you imagine taking golf lessons from a club pro that would say "why are you using a sand-wedge(?!).... you need a pitching wedge you moron(!). You are an idiot! You have never played golf before".
Trading is this kind of activity,traders are characters and successful even more so.
Let's face it better to have a trader than fraud like Xela,Nodoji and the likes.