Is it possible to make $50 to $70 per day with a 4K account in YM ??

Quote from showyouwang:

The best independent traders are independent for a reason. They like the freedom it brings, and they aren't well known. Read a few Market Wizard books. But if the trader is really exceptional, if you gave them millions they could do well with that as well. (ie Mark Cook)

Comparing institutions to daytrading independently doesn't really fly. Daytraders manage every facet of their business and have a complete understanding of how their trading works. In institutions, the responsibilities are delegated.

Don't judge daytraders based on institutional standards, and don't judge institutions based on daytrading standards. Daytrading could give you 500%+ on relatively small capital, but a 50% return from an institution that manages millions is nothing to laugh at.

Ah, the voice of reason.

Too bad it's like throwing pearls before swine.

JJ
 
Quote from GTS:

Apparently we are in the company of many multi-millionaires in this thread - congrats.

Either that or they have the ability and just choose not to use it.

Plenty of liquidity on YM, if the claims about the ease of large returns are true there is no reason why anyone who can do it would not be able to scale into the millions before running into serious slippage problems.

LOL - how the hell would you know anything about what you're talking about from an experiental point of view?#! :confused:

It's always the wankers who think they know what something is ... but they haven't got a clue, just wanking away.

JJ
 
OK, I give you guys one example. Last time I did a quick stats on Puretick, they were making I think 17 pts, with 5-7 trades averaged a day. that is 10-12 YM gains a day, after commission.

Oh, slightly offtopic, but there is a doubletop with RSI divergence on the Dow... :)
 
Quote from JimmyJam:

LOL - how the hell would you know anything about what you're talking about from an experiental point of view?#! :confused:
I'll take that answer to be a no on the multi-millionaire question.

Why not?
 
Has been this thread hijacked by the “nouvelle” Midas Kings that everything they touch turn into gold? Or What?.

If you’re so successful why bother posting here??? We’re just trying to give some quantifiable parameters (not just some random delirious comments of superiority) to discuss how much is too much when trading?

Showing off about how good are you at trading (or at basic technical analysis), or how easy is to become millionaire or how brainless are people who have a different trading approach, only deepen my doubts about the veracity of your comments.

If this discussion is going to stay at this level, I stop posting in this thread and let you free to keep “selling unachievable dreams” to small traders looking for advice. Otherwise, I’m happy to keep discussing the subject in a mature, serious and professional way.

jjrvat
 
To correct a couple of points I have made that may have been misinterpreted:
1. institutions certainly do use leverage, but are aware of the level and danger of it. in my opinion 800 percent levered can be okay on bond contracts, with leverage calculated as gross contract value over supporting assets. equity market neutral levered at 800 is on the high side, and FX also. The natural leverage in credit default swap contracts is also manageable, but personally I keep the level down due to continued tightness of spreads. Emerging market assets run lower levels of leverage.

2. I have nothing against short term trading, but believe the commissions are key at this level, and VWAP execuion by Lehman or Goldman becomes as important as the system.

Scalping though and trading rumours and news is a world away from this framework though, and in my opinion is statistical noise.

bear in mind though this is only my view, and the funds I co-manage today dropped over forty million USD, so am always happy to engage in debate with the informed.

(Those in garages need not apply, but thanks for providing my liquidity)
 
Quote from jjrvat:

Has been this thread hijacked by the “nouvelle” Midas Kings that everything they touch turn into gold? Or What?.

If you’re so successful why bother posting here??? We’re just trying to give some quantifiable parameters (not just some random delirious comments of superiority) to discuss how much is too much when trading?

Showing off about how good are you at trading (or at basic technical analysis), or how easy is to become millionaire or how brainless are people who have a different trading approach, only deepen my doubts about the veracity of your comments.

If this discussion is going to stay at this level, I stop posting in this thread and let you free to keep “selling unachievable dreams” to small traders looking for advice. Otherwise, I’m happy to keep discussing the subject in a mature, serious and professional way.

jjrvat

Good comment jjrvat, and I'll take you at your word on that one.

The basic questions was "Is it possible to make $50 to $70 per day with a 4K account in YM??"

... and several traders here have shown the answer to be an unequivocal YES provided you know how to do so, and NO if you don't.

Now if you think the traders who do know how to do so are going to explain what they do to the traders who don't know how to do so, you've got another thought coming ... and if that is what you want, to tell you the truth, I think you're time would actually be better spent with with Purtick.

There, I've said it twice.

Jimmy jam
 
Quote from Cavendish:

To correct a couple of points I have made that may have been misinterpreted:
1. institutions certainly do use leverage, but are aware of the level and danger of it. in my opinion 800 percent levered can be okay on bond contracts, with leverage calculated as gross contract value over supporting assets. equity market neutral levered at 800 is on the high side, and FX also. The natural leverage in credit default swap contracts is also manageable, but personally I keep the level down due to continued tightness of spreads. Emerging market assets run lower levels of leverage.

2. I have nothing against short term trading, but believe the commissions are key at this level, and VWAP execuion by Lehman or Goldman becomes as important as the system.

Scalping though and trading rumours and news is a world away from this framework though, and in my opinion is statistical noise.

bear in mind though this is only my view, and the funds I co-manage today dropped over forty million USD, so am always happy to engage in debate with the informed.

(Those in garages need not apply, but thanks for providing my liquidity)

JJ

please dont answer to this as this is for high school graduates and above.
 
and indeed to get back on topic, I think that these returns mentioned are of course possible, but I would want anyone new at this difficult business to know that 1 percent a day four out of five trading days is an extremely tough call, I would try and start aiming at three to five percent a month consistently, with standard deviation at an annualised fifteen percent or so. these are stellar figures. i'd also suggest running some stress tests on the portfolio being traded, and see how it holds up under some of these, to focus the mind. depending on level of understanding as well, maybe running costless out of the money puts alongside a long strategy as a disaster hedge.

again, just my two pennies.
 
Quote from asap:

JJ

please dont answer to this as this is for high school graduates and above.

ROTFLMAO :D

Oh, that one brought tears to my eyes.

Thanks asap, laughing is always a good thing.
***
Making $50 to $75 a day on a 4k account is as far away from managing a multi million dollar account institutional account as the Earth is away from the planet Pluto.

I'm sorry you tools can't see that for what it is, but it's true.

Now, since you don't have anything to teach me, and you're too dense for me to teach you, I'll have to just call it a day.

Good trading,

Jimmy Jam
 
Back
Top