Perhaps I miscommunicated, that's not my intention.
System A (Price Action) and System B (Price Volume relationship) are not in the same ball park. It's not even comparing apples to oranges, not even close.
Everything you describe is accurate for System A but misapplied to System B from B's perspective and experience. A's perspective is that everything is bullshit outside it's own understanding, including System B.
B accepts this.
Changing perspective requires work. Very few individuals recognize an opportunity when it presents itself.
Post a PV chart and what you perceive as a fake out or false signal with a request for clarity.
Better if the chart has open space at the hard right edge.
The above is a topic for a different thread.
Most folks never engage in the work to understand the basic granularity of the markets and their fundamental relationships. That's why day trading is difficult to impossible.