What about days where the net result came from shorting in a bull market that had a daily red bar?
What about days where the net result came from longs and shorts?
What's your argument now?
Still dumb luck or edge?
The market can do three things, up, down or range, once you determine that in your timeframe or timeframes of choice the rest is following a plan.
As far as holding a swing position vs daytrading, daytrading allows you to use leverage that would be seen as irresponsible as swings, something to consider.
The way I see it, too many inexperienced and/or failed traders giving opinions in public boards.
Yes it's a long road to making it, but it's not a pipe dream, and anyone that has not tasted consistent success should refrain from calling success particularly in index futures, impossible to attain.
Last but not least, got to laugh at the plethora of people blaming HFT and bots, only time I think about them is when I read public boards.
Fact is, understanding what needs to be done is an extremely long road, full of scars, sweat and even tears, one not only has to overcome that but in the end have the same will you had from Day 1, and sometimes even more, guess how many are willing to endure that? And suddenly the 1% does not seem so strange.