Quote from Brandonf:
I'd agree with not allowing him into the country, but I dont really see how a carefully monitored trading account would cause any problems.
I agree with this but as others have noted, current US security measures means IB likely has no choice.Quote from zdreg:
do not be so rough on this man. being born in baghdad is not a sin. for all you know he could be a persecuted kurd or christen from iraq. even being a moslem is not an excuse for this treatment.
the questions are intrusive and the answers will reveal nothing of value.
I am curious if the op would be allowed to open an account if he answered any of the questions in the affirmative? aka - is denial a foregone conclusion or would he simply be placed on some "monitor-closely" list?1) Do you currently hold a passport from Iraq?
2) Do you hold Iraq citizenship?
3) Do you have business dealings in Iraq?
4) Do you hold any financial accounts in Iraq?
5) Do you have plans ever to back/settle in Iraq?
Quote from 50_Bip:
Why don't you choose a new broker there Einstein?? Don't blame IB for following up and requiring additional information on you. For all they know, you are an international terrorist wanting to launder dirty money through them. If I ran a brokerage, I'd think the same thing!
Quote from hayder:
1) Do you currently hold a passport from Iraq?
NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS. I APPLIED WITH MY BRITISH PASSPORT.
2) Do you hold Iraq citizenship?
NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS. YOU KNOW IâM A BRITISH CITIZEN. YOU NEED TO KNOW WHERE MY GREAT GRANDMOTHER WAS BORN TOO???
3) Do you have business dealings in Iraq?
NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS
4) Do you hold any financial accounts in Iraq?
NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS
5) Do you have plans ever to back/settle in Iraq?
IF AND WHEN I PLAN TO MOVE ANYWHERE I WILL INFORM MY BROKER AND BANK IN GOOD TIME. IâM LIVING IN DUBAI NOW. YOU HAVE NO RIGHT TO ASK ME WHAT MY LIFE PLANS ARE AND WHAT UNDERWEAR I PLAN TO WEAR TOMORROW.
Quote from CPTrader:
Everyone from the Middle East is a terrorist or money launderer.
Everyone from Nigeria is a fruadster
Everyone from Afirca is poor, hungry and unrefined.
Everyone from Mexico is an illegal immigrant.
So sad.....the dumbification of America will pull the great country down.
Quote from Kicking:
The last question about his plans to go back to Iraq is a bit too much . It is none of IB's business. The first couple of questions are legitimate given the new compliance requirements and the
war in Iraq. Certainly IB could have made an effort not to indispose a potential client, this is not very good business. But again IB has proved to have absolutely idiotic ways of treating their customers. So I am not surprised.
So is there racism ? Probably not , although when I see the stream of racist comments on here I wouldn't be surprised there is some of it at IB compliance dept. as well.
I am not going to take a stand for muslims in that part of the world, everybody is wary of them justifiably after what has been done in their name. But if someone has a British passport, he should be treated with a minimum of respect.
Remember also that probably the guy wouldn' t have a problem opening an account in the first place, if a clique of criminals by incompetence, backed by millions of morons, had not invaded and destroyed Iraq and the life of its people.