Introvert? or Extrovert?

I consider myself to be


  • Total voters
    71
I think the majority would be introverted. Traders, people that write code and other jobs that don’t require a lot of personal interaction. After taking the Meyers- Briggs test a few times I am definitively an INTJ - introverted, intuitive, Thinking, Judgemental. It’s the second least common personality with 2 percent of the population being this way. It would be interesting if you posted a link for the test and did a pill for the results. I bet the people here would have similar traits.


I appreciate the feedback. I actually got enough data to know I need to take this in another direction. At this point I'm certain the delineating factor between those who have trouble following their system and those who don't isn't introvert vs. extrovert. I'm leaning towards the idea that it comes down to these two key factors:
1. Can the trader tell himself what to do or believe without bending to social proof?
2. Does he have a working system? I think most people can subconsciously intuit that their system is crap, so they don't trust it to begin with.

That's my stance for now. Always in pursuit of the truth, though.
 
The effectiveness of a futures trader is not solely determined by whether they are an introvert or extrovert. Both personality types can excel in futures trading, and their success is influenced by various factors beyond their personality traits. Here are some considerations to understand how introverts and extroverts can leverage their strengths in the world of futures trading:

Introverts in Futures Trading:
1. Focused Analysis: Introverts tend to excel in tasks that require deep focus and introspection. In futures trading, this can be advantageous as introverts often have a natural inclination towards thorough research, meticulous analysis, and developing well-defined trading strategies.
2. Disciplined Execution: Introverts typically display high levels of discipline and self-control. These qualities can be invaluable when it comes to sticking to a trading plan, following risk management strategies, and resisting impulsive decisions driven by external factors or market noise.
3. Independent Decision Making: Introverts often thrive in solitary environments and are comfortable making independent decisions. In futures trading, this self-reliance allows introverts to trust their analysis, follow their instincts, and maintain a consistent approach to trading without being overly influenced by external opinions or market sentiment.

Extroverts in Futures Trading:
1. Networking and Information Gathering: Extroverts thrive in social settings, making it easier for them to build networks and engage with industry professionals. This can provide them with access to valuable market insights, trading ideas, and diverse perspectives that can enhance their decision-making process.
2. Active Engagement in Market Events: Extroverts tend to enjoy active engagement and participation in market events, conferences, and trading communities. Their outgoing nature allows them to exchange ideas, discuss strategies, and stay informed about market trends in real-time, which can be advantageous for adapting to dynamic market conditions.
3. Effective Communication: Extroverts excel in communication skills, which can be beneficial when articulating trading ideas, negotiating positions, and establishing relationships with brokers, clients, or counterparties. Clear and effective communication can enhance their ability to navigate the futures market successfully.

In summary, both introverts and extroverts have unique qualities that can contribute to their success as futures traders. Introverts often leverage their focused analysis, disciplined execution, and independent decision-making, while extroverts tap into their networking abilities, active engagement in market events, and effective communication skills. Ultimately, a successful futures trader is not solely defined by their personality type but by their ability to leverage their strengths, adapt to market conditions, implement effective strategies, and maintain discipline in their trading approach.

Source?
 
Source?
%%
CERTAINLY true[his comments] for business or capital markets in general;
my source is extensive observation. Another source= common sense
I have no idea about what % of personalities, do derivatives or % profitable LOL.
but looks like he[MarkB or CHAT GP= same] is right; even though small circle =trade derivatives\ compared to business or capital markets.........................
 
I'm wanting to collect some data for a hypothesis I have about the type of people that are attracted to trading for a living. Can you help? Thanks in advance!
Extroverts may find it easier to seek advice and learn from experienced traders, accelerating their growth as traders themselves.
 
Extroverts may find it easier to seek advice and learn from experienced traders, accelerating their growth as traders themselves.
Extroverts make for better leaders, they gain the info from others then get the introverts to trade it for them.
 
Majority of introverts. I guess we found peace being by ourselves. Someone said before that trading is a lonely profession, and looking at how miserable the "Hook up" section of the forum is, that might be true.

Do introverts enjoy posting on forums? Can someone with expertise in the subject chip in?
 
Majority of introverts. I guess we found peace being by ourselves. Someone said before that trading is a lonely profession, and looking at how miserable the "Hook up" section of the forum is, that might be true.

Do introverts enjoy posting on forums? Can someone with expertise in the subject chip in?

Lol, yeah the hook up section is why I started this thread in the first place.

My take on this is that people begin trading in the first place because they are seeking validation for something probably related to their intelligence or worth as a human being. That's why majority are introverts. We come to the market thinking that if we can be successful then that will prove once and for all that "everyone was wrong about me" or some such thing. When it turns out not so well they come to forums like this seeking validation from others for their ideas not realizing that validation is a precious and limited resource amongst the group and no one really has it to give.
I don't think introverts truly enjoy posting on forums. It may be more so that there are moments in time that it becomes more painful not to post then to risk commenting for the chance that maybe someone will say something nice.
 
Lol, yeah the hook up section is why I started this thread in the first place.

My take on this is that people begin trading in the first place because they are seeking validation for something probably related to their intelligence or worth as a human being. That's why majority are introverts. We come to the market thinking that if we can be successful then that will prove once and for all that "everyone was wrong about me" or some such thing. When it turns out not so well they come to forums like this seeking validation from others for their ideas not realizing that validation is a precious and limited resource amongst the group and no one really has it to give.
I don't think introverts truly enjoy posting on forums. It may be more so that there are moments in time that it becomes more painful not to post then to risk commenting for the chance that maybe someone will say something nice.

If you come to this forum seeking validation you are in for a treat. These wankers will rip you apart from head to toe, I have not seen much concentrated anger in ages. We are ready for a fight around here. :D

I sometimes post on futures.io and man, that place is nice, people are so polite there. But here, this forum is pure fun, raw mental diarrhea, sometimes even harder than Twitter, which I like, I am not gonna lie.
 
Back
Top