Intermarket analysis with Vantage Point

rcreal,

Why did you say pricing bands and probable highs and lows aren't useful? Personally, I don't trade off, e. g., Bollinger Bands, but I refer to it once in a while and I think it's useful to at least some traders. And what problems do you see with Neural Nets and Genetic Algorithms (whatever it is I have no idea). Can you clarify?

stock.




Originally posted by rcreal
Percentages themselves mean nothing ...

Heck, I can easily predict the 5 day moving average tomorrow with 80% accuracy.

I explored Neural Nets, Genetic Algorithms, and such for quite a while. I did get some good predictions of pricing bands ... probable highs and lows. Still not too useful for trading.

Using trading systems recognizing price reaction work the best for me.
More...
 
AAA,

That's exactly what I want to find out before saying trading off such relationships is problematic. Perhaps, I don't have as much experience as you have in the markets, but I do believe there's order in the markets. And, long-term relationships are built of short-term ones.

I'm not looking for the holy grail, but I do believe that some systems are better than others in capturing such market relationships. I don't know which one is the best, but I've seen systems that are better than others.

stock.


Originally posted by AAAintheBeltway
stockoptionist,

I agree there are relationships that generally work out over time. Example, Fed cuts rates, generally the economy improves. But the question I was addressing is whether or not you can trade off these relationships. I think that is much more problematic.
More...
 
Intermarket Analysis works for the long term... but changes now and then ranging from a year to 10or 20 odd years eg a method called decoupling where once coupled markets tend to "decouple" some time in the future; and i'm taking years. If you read the book "Intermarket Analysis" by Murphy he mentions all this. He also has given positive reference to Vantage Point. But what if once correlated markets starts to "decouple" what then.... all software calculation for the neural network modules in Vantage point would have to change right?! Now THAT'S NOT mentioned..... are they aware of that???!!!!

I have tried VP for a year now... Yes the sales person was pushy and being in the UK wanted me to find other sales for him in the UK..... !!

I, like others, find that there PMA was good, but their predicted H & L was in accurate and useless at times. You are better off using candlestick charting which is effective using metastock with a plugin.... which still doesn't come anywhere near VP price.

I Really want get my money back on this, but it's been a year and i haven't really made any greater amounts of money from it than to just use my own trading ways/rules.... i have just made more money from experience and getting better.... but not from the software!

Anybody know how i can get my money back from these please.
Or if anyone wants to test it out for themselves.... maybe i missed something....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top