There are reasons why you don't read on forums about people making money:I have never seen winning traders on forums who demonstrated any consistent ability to trade and win. I reckon the failure rate is closer to 99% if not higher.
http://www.elitetrader.com/et/index...itable-with-the-es.286440/page-9#post-4040318
But it is true that most people cannot consistently make money. If saw it at the desk where all these orders came together from a big broker. Marginal calls all around.