The problem with routing to "crap" BATS is probably there because we have selected option to route to cheapest destination or a deal between IB and BATS as it might be the cheapest for them.
Those types of magic fills you describe are pretty much normal, however to be honest I found them to be more favourable for me than national best...
I don't do much size often in one trade so maybe that's why I have better fills...
I am really trying to avoid BATS, for me it looks like you never get good fills there, you get fill only when market crashes through your limit. I would be happy to have an option to exclude BATS from smart router...
You have to bare in mind that it looks that IB has much more liquidity pools hidden that they advertise to customers. Look at PBP trades, I found that there is maybe 20% of volume in this done via traditional exchanges, the rest is unknown for me, probably some dark pools or IB own system. Simply speaking >> cheating
.
Those types of magic fills you describe are pretty much normal, however to be honest I found them to be more favourable for me than national best...
I don't do much size often in one trade so maybe that's why I have better fills...
I am really trying to avoid BATS, for me it looks like you never get good fills there, you get fill only when market crashes through your limit. I would be happy to have an option to exclude BATS from smart router...
You have to bare in mind that it looks that IB has much more liquidity pools hidden that they advertise to customers. Look at PBP trades, I found that there is maybe 20% of volume in this done via traditional exchanges, the rest is unknown for me, probably some dark pools or IB own system. Simply speaking >> cheating
.