"Intelligent Investor" fans

Do you think by following an investing strategy like the one outlined in the intelligent investor, one could achieve around 20%/yr in the markets nowadays? I ask because of some reviews on amazon such as this one that say the method is somewhat outdated:

For all it's strengths, this book as well as "Securities Analysis" have a common weakness which is that the ways that Graham found 'value' investments are much more difficult to find today. Value investing has been around for half a century now and has recently been making a comeback because of the bursting of the tech bubble. As Graham also states, the more prevalent a certain approach to investing becomes, the more diluted its earnings potential becomes. Opportunities such as 'net-nets' (stocks whose market value fall below their book value) are extremely rare to find today. It is up to the reader to discern how he/she can take advantage and apply his ideas to the market today. (Which the best books usually do)
 
One recent net -net stock was K-Mart. It was indeed far below it's book value. The management took the company into bankruptcy, killed the existing stock, came out of bankruptcy with new stock. The holders of the old stock got zip. I did not know that was a doable thing but I knew a guy that had a considerable part of his life savings in the old K-Mart stock. The management got the gold mine and he got the shaft.
 
Back
Top