Quote from Sam Mcgee:
I've heard complaints about immigrants but I've heard worse complaints from employers who can't get Americans to work and have to resort to immigrants.
Im saying that the main argument used against immigrants, legal or illegal, is that they are taking American's jobs away. If you go by that reasoning, then you are saying that immigrants are less desirable than American born people who aren't working.
Why couldn't we just make a deal to trade people? Heck, we could even sweeten the deal, we'll two Americans south who don't want to work for every immigrant they send from Mexico who wants to work.
Legal immigrants has nothing to do with it. We are talking about ILLEGAL immigrants.
the point is, that these are not normal times. When people talk about spending $500 billion to stimulate the economy, then it is FIRST time to extract people who are working here illegally.
In the Depression years, several million Americans would be HAPPY for the jobs being done by illegals.
When you have 3 kids and no income, you would be amazed what a long unemployed roofer would do to feed his family, including doing the work of migrant farmers or working in a processing plant.
When you have an imbalance of labor, then give the legally-here Americans transportation and set them up in areas that have jobs being done by ILLegals. Procesing plants, farmers, whatever.
Believe it or not, there are unemployed white collar workers, programmers, etc. already here who could do at least SOME of the work by Indians coming over here as new immigrants with their technical degrees. I worked with plenty of them in the past.
The govt needs to expend SOME efforts to match some of these people already here, even if needing to asist them moving from Connecticut to Sioux Falls, South Dakota.