Originally posted by Vishnu
- the FDIC stuff was interesting. I didn't know that the FDIC itself lacks money.
- its true that unemployment was 28% a full four years after the crash of '29. However, Hoover also raised taxes a lot during that period, dampening both business and consumer spending. There was zero fiscal stimulus after the 1929 crash which is very different from the current Fed policy.
- there is a simple reason P/E is important. Eventually, if P/Es remain low and interest rates remain low then nobody is incentified to remain public. Companies will do MBOs and LBOs because the money will be cheap. This assumes some economic growth but in the long-run the economy has never not grown. All arguments assume some resilience in the economy, no matter how many "dips" we do.
- the Smoot Hawley tariff act preceded the crash but did not take full effect until later but the expectation of higher tariffs had a chilling effect. Smoot-Hawley was an across the board tariff which resulted in mass shrinkage of global trade. There is no comparison to a few steel and textile tariff increases right now.
- economic policy is completely different now than in 1929. Although Greenspan and crew are far from perfect its like comparing a brain surgeon with someone who cures people with leeches.
It's true that there are differences in regards to the taxes and
money supply. The money supply (M1, M2, M3) today is currently
increasing as per government policy; during the Great Depression
the money supply shrunk which was one of the key causes of
the depression. The government under Hoover also had a
policy of "hands-off" and let the economy perform necessary
"liquidation". Also the taxes greatly increased during the
depression which put a further damper on business and
recovery.
Smoot-Hawley was not signed into law until June 17, 1930
by President Hoover. While the current tariffs do not match
the level of the 1930 tariffs; the trend is towards greater
& increased tariffs which will generally put pressure on
world-wide business & trade.
- Greg