Quote from NoDoji:
Blox, I too found that leaving stop and target in place works best, but I'm still struggling with targets.
Friday I had 4 trades in crude oil (CL):
First was a SLABL in pre-market and since it had already broken down very hard was extremely overextended, I covered at the first sign of buyers for a very quick gain on this momentum play.
Then I had a SHABL when price double topped following a strong run up. It was counter-trend and I had a .20 target. I got .11 in my favor and was then stopped out b/e.
Next a WTSAFBD, using a breakdown of the 20 bar EMA, so I would be with-trend. This is the trade where I let previous trades cause me to be way too conservative with my target and leave a lot of money on the table. In choosing my target for this trade, I decided that since this was the first breakdown of the 20 EMA following a strong uptrend, price would do what it usually does and bounce at the lower channel line, then bounce and allow a with-trend re-entry to the short side for a real move down when the rally stalled. Sure enough, price tested the lower line, stalled, retested it, found support and I exited there, waiting for my expected re-entry signal. Had I left my stop at b/e and just waited, I would've caught a piece of a further .57 move. I was frustrated several days in a row letting $200-$300 winners reverse to b/e trying to let my targets be hit and allowed that frustration to bleed into a brand new trade. All week I'd been targeting a .70 move in CL and I gave it away by making assumptions about what price would do.
After that large move, I had a SHABL with-trend entry, selling the small bounce the moment it failed, and set my target .05 below the previous pivot low because price had broken down so hard that a reversal there was likely. I lowered my target a bit when price reached it and tightened my stop to target. Initial target was attained on the pivot just a few ticks from the pivot low, so this trade worked out very well.
Normally I set initial profit targets at a measured lower low in a downtrend, measured higher high in an uptrend. If trading breakouts, I set initial targets at a level similar to the most common breakout levels. If CL has been breaking out .30-.40 then I'll target .30-.40 on a breakout trade.
Trend channel lines and previous S/R levels also help with targets, but sometimes limit your profits unless you're scaling out.