IB Alternative Choices?

Quote from DonKee:

It's an IB problem.

Anyone using tradestation for e-minis?

Feedback welcome.

Thanks.

Earlier IB YM = 11903
Tradestation YM 11911

Not a connection or exchange problem.

Not a 'fast market'

Probably need 2 accounts these days...

Too bad. IB should signal 'bad data' at least when the lag gets too wide.
 
I think most the problems people report are down to the internet and ISPs.

ISPs just don't offer the quality of connection needed for serious trading and IB's internet technology doesn't do anything clever to overcome internet unreliability.

Hence, I suppose the problem is ultimately an IB problem.
 
Im thinking with all the IB adverts on CNBC, that since they have gone mass market and can no longer properly manage their retail IT systems for the larger user base they have now.
 
Quote from Businessman:

Im thinking with all the IB adverts on CNBC, that they have gone mass market and can no longer manage their retail IT systems for the larger user base they have now.

BINGO


They were great when they actually cared about their customers and growing their business. Now that Joe Shmoe who watches CNBC knows about IB, then don't give a rats ass about reliability any longer.
 
Quote from Businessman:

Recent server outages cost me about 5K in losses. I can handle the losses but what amazed me was that it took so long get it fixed.

Im hope this just a bad patch, and things will get back to normal soon.

These IB problems have forced me to move to BE much quicker than I'd like, resulting in washes that would have been good trades. No money lost, but what's the point in trading at all?
 
Quote from slacker:

Earlier IB YM = 11903
Tradestation YM 11911

Not a connection or exchange problem.

Not a 'fast market'

Probably need 2 accounts these days...

Too bad. IB should signal 'bad data' at least when the lag gets too wide.

There was a time that Tradestation's data would be behind IB's d, but not these days.... And Tradestation does not really have a reputation of being fast and reliable.:mad:
 
Quote from BCE:

You know just one morning of bad data feeds and not being able to trade can wipe out any advantage of lower commissions, at least from the number of trades I do daily. Reliable data feeds is THE most important feature of any broker. Today you've failed this test IB.
 
Quote from slacker:

Earlier IB YM = 11903
Tradestation YM 11911

Too bad. IB should signal 'bad data' at least when the lag gets too wide.
Interactive Brokers System Status
Updated: 2006/10/10 11:26:01 EST Refreshed: 11:56 EST (Next Refresh: 60 seconds)


Exchange Availability
Stat Message Created/Updated

To ECBOT,GLOBEX Traders:
US futures market data may, once again, be delayed or unavailable for some customers.

[Mesg Id: 43961] 2006/10/10 11:26
2006/10/10 11:26

To AMEX,BOX,CBOE,ISE,PHLX,PSE Traders:
AMEX,BOX,CBOE,ISE,PHLX,PSE market data is delayed or unavailable.

[Mesg Id: 43859] 2006/10/10 10:33
2006/10/10 10:33

To AMEX,BOX,CBOE,ISE,ONE,PHLX,PSE Traders:
AMEX,BOX,CBOE,ISE,ONE,PHLX,PSE market data is delayed or unavailable.

[Mesg Id: 43854] 2006/10/10 10:12
2006/10/10 10:13

To BOX,CBOE,ISE,PHLX Traders:
AMEX BOX,CBOE,ISE,PHLX PSE market data maybe delayed or unavailable.

[Mesg Id: 43847]
 
The problem always seems to be with IB, and yet they always refer to it as 'problem with the exchange', ie, 'market data unavailable due to a technical problem at the exchange', etc.


What a load.

Not only that, they also are 'eliminating' some of their 'bulletins', for example, they earlier had sent out that Globex was down / intermittent, etc, (for some customers) (hey, apparently we all qualify) and then, they sent out another bulletin, that the 'problem' was 'resolved', (right at the exact highs, coincidentally). Then, the problems apparently reaapeared, but instead of continuing with their 'message cache', they have opted to remove their earlier messages of problems, and problems fixed, etc. I saw and read all the bulletins, and they seem to be 'jacking' these around also.

Can you say, 'pull the wool over their eyes'?

What I would like to know is, if there are other systems that are and have operated without problems, then that flies in the face of IB's bulletins that the 'problems' are witht he exchange.

Anyone working with other sytems that are operating normally? If so, will you list them?

IB's systems, it seems, are, (as per their phone message recording) 'All sytems functioning normally', yeah right, more like, 'SNAFU'.
 

Attachments

Back
Top