I want to learn to trade futures!!

sent you a PM.

Quote from mike281:

ProfitTkgFool - thank you for your insight!! I guess I should have been more clear in my post - I wasn't necessarily looking for someone to teach me - more or less "hold my hand" in getting started. I do understand yours (and others) point of view - it certainly would be an overwhelming task to take on a student. Several of the books I have read have made reference to finding a mentor to help a person get started, so in so many words, that's what I was trying to do I guess.

By the way, I didn't mean to imply that I was looking for free advice either!! I just thought that I might find a seasoned pro here who wasn't looking to necessarily get rich off of students like me with the same structured program that they fed to everyone who was willing to pay them. I've heard of so many people in the business world (in general) who have done well for themselves and randomly want to help a new guy out, just for the sake of doing so...and even though a rare occurance, I thought it was worth asking.

I really shot myself in the foot with my first post on what seems to be a great resource for traders....:eek:
 
Quote from mike281:

Thanks for your support!! I guess I am nieve to believe that there are people out there who have done well for themselves and want to help a new guy get started in a profession that they have excelled in for themselves.......

The forum is called "hook up" - so that's what I was attempting to use it for. Sorry to upset you so much!?!

Hi mike281,

There are most definitely folks who are willing and able to do this... I suggest the following link:

http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=83604

If you see value in studying these methods and have questions, the current thread can be found here:

http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=113310

Best wishes in your journey!
 
Quote from mike281:


....on what seems to be a great resource for traders....:eek:
Quote from snowhite:

My time is worth too much to train a newbie like yourself.

With quotes like the one above you will find your statement a little out of place. There can be and are some very insightfull and helpfull people here, but the likes of the above ALMOST make it not worth the time here.

If you wish to learn keep looking for that mentor and be prepared to pay for his time.

Make em' pretty, Chris
 
Quote from ehorn:

Hi mike281,

There are most definitely folks who are willing and able to do this... I suggest the following link:

http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=83604

If you see value in studying these methods and have questions, the current thread can be found here:

http://www.elitetrader.com/vb/showthread.php?s=&threadid=113310

Best wishes in your journey!

Mike

If nothing else, STAY AWAY FROM THESE LINKS. SpyderTrader is just the disciple of JACK HERSHEY - a clueless trader who invented a Rube Goldberg machine of horrendous complexity that takes many months to learn, will assist you in losing your money, and then take many months to unlearn.

Do some serious searching on what many people here say against Jack Hershey. He is the Pied Piper leading newbie traders astray!!!!!

Good lord, save yourself from the months to years of grief

TZ
 
Quote from mike281:

I've heard of so many people in the business world (in general) who have done well for themselves and randomly want to help a new guy out, just for the sake of doing so...and even though a rare occurance, I thought it was worth asking.

That is what I was trying to tell you above.

If you are going to succeed in a field with a 95% failure rate, there really is no short cut. What the 2 people said about putting in screen time is the closest thing you will get to the truth.

The only thing you are likely to get from your request for a mentor, is discovering what most of us did - 99% of the people offering services, advisories, methods, tradestation plugins, ebay offerings, spam emails, "mentoring" etc. offer you a useless service.

Bettertrades, Teach Me to Trade, Investools, and others cross the country, luring in tends of thousands to their seminars who pay $6000 to $25,000 in "tuition" trying to learn.

Imagine trying to become a brain surgeon after 3 days of classes?

One way to start, is with the attitude that this will take a while to learn, that you are quite likely to never make any money, that you will invest thousands of hours and lose many thousands of dollars, that you will have many early hopes of success dashed, and many other things. And maybe after years of dedicated hard work, you might just find success. But I would say perhaps 1% of people do. And it most likely won't be at the hand of a "nice guy who wants to mentor you" but by YOUR efforts after a huge amount of time learning how price action works, from a lot of screen time.
 
You've just discouraged most of the people here who trying to learn how to trade. Intuition is something born with, not something can be learned. That's why the low success rate of your teaching proved that trading CANNOT ALWAYS be taught. It requires both nature and nurture work together to shape trading ability.

The question is how can you spot this person can be or cannot be a good trader if he receive a good mentorship? This is a good entry point to avoid wasting time with somebody that can never be taught. What kind of traits (come at born) that should be looking for.

Quote from ProfitTakgFool:

Mike,

Successful trading is based mostly on intuition and discretion.
 
TZ, you couldn't be more wrong. But if the OP is lazy, then yes I'd agree with you to stay away.


Quote from TraderZones:

Mike

If nothing else, STAY AWAY FROM THESE LINKS. SpyderTrader is just the disciple of JACK HERSHEY - a clueless trader who invented a Rube Goldberg machine of horrendous complexity that takes many months to learn, will assist you in losing your money, and then take many months to unlearn.

Do some serious searching on what many people here say against Jack Hershey. He is the Pied Piper leading newbie traders astray!!!!!

Good lord, save yourself from the months to years of grief

TZ
 
Here is few advices (for intra day trading only):

1) Pick only one market and study it inside out. If you live in US and can not trade during regular hours. You have Hong Kong HSI futures, Nikkey 225 on SGX, European Eurex futures like DAX and Euro Stoxx and few others.
2) Stay away from spot forex, it is not a real market but a virtual trading world within each broker. If you settle on currencies CME futures on 6 majors are your best bet.
3) Pick a chart that is not fixed time fractal: tick, volume or range. The reason is that these charts only move when something is happening, where fixed time charts move regardless. This will make price action much clearer.
4) Spend a lot of screen time to learn price action from above mentioned chart. You can read Wycoff day trading bible to get better understanding of price action. It can be downloaded for free from many websites,
5) Settle on 1 or maximum 2 indicators. Price action is enough to place trades, but indicators will help you to interpret it better and faster.
6) Learn to interpret Market Depth, this will save you from entering against immediate supports or resistances and being shaken out of position too quickly.

Do not try to study all of this at once. Add one item at a time. If you need some additional clarifications and materials let me know. Good luck and enjoy.

Regards,
redduke
 
Quote from mike281:

Looking for mentoring help in futures in general. I currently trade electricity for my job (and have for about four years now). I trade in the Real Time markets which primarily rely on fundamental analysis rather than technical. I'm interested in learning futures and technical analysis, but would like to get some first hand experience with a pro before doing it on my own. I have read several books but haven't jumped in yet - not sure if that's good or bad?! Anyway, I live in the Pittsburgh, PA area and am willing to drive several hours if necessary to do this, if someone is willing. Please let me know if you or someone you know might be interested.

Thanks!!!
Mike

I'm in a similar position to the OP (though I'm pretty sure I got turned down for employment at the firm he works for). What people are telling you is the best advice you will get. I'd love to have a seasoned mentor too, but I don't see it happening any time soon.
 
Back
Top