Quote from crgarcia:
I profited BIG from the stock market rebound, buying during recession.
I posted a journal with REAL TIME TRADES.
(they were long term trades)
So I challenge frequent traders who SAY they are profitable, to post their real time trades.
Do you accept the challenge?
Real time trades only, anything else is charlatanry!
I don't care at all.Quote from Fireplace:
You have to wonder why a 'successful' long term trader (ie Garcia) would care THIS MUCH about what short term traders are doing and the success they are having.
Intellectual property?Quote from Bob111:
once again-what's the point? i have no problem to show you EOD PnL
but real time trades-no way.it's my intellectual property and i prefer to keep it private.
but before we do that-show us how exactly you profit BIG. i did post my 2009 statement in your other thread....so show me yours YTD
Wisdom, I will prove all daytraders lose.Quote from Pekelo:
Just out of curiosity, what is the payoff/prize???
Yes, cash. I was cash since "chinese surprise" Feb 27, 2007.Quote from Red_Ink_inc:
I posted 3+ years of daily blotters on this very website. Though I guess that's not good enough for a brain dead wanker like you is it?
Feel free to call Genesis and ask if those numbers were real provided you can find someone there who wont tell you to go fly a kite.
Nice that you did well during the rebound. How did you make out during the crash? Let me guess you were skillfully 100% cash, right?
Yes, and the first lesson to profit it's not to lose money.Quote from Petsamo:
As a profitable trader or successful person, you should teach people how to strike it rich. It's a way to "give back to the community" without giving cash away. There's minimal time loss on the part of the giver when all you do is post your trades.
Maybe you are the communist, and the one resented at people who made big $ from the market rebound?Quote from jd7419:
Garcia loser,
I have alot of patience for the idiots on this board. Out of the commies, stockturder, and the other mental midgets you are the first person to be put on ignore by me. You are a sad sad kid I hope. I pray you are a not an old man with kids, God help them.
Yes, even I have difficulty finding my own journals as time passes.Quote from Bolimomo:
Yes. He posts his trade "real time". But he "trades" only about once every year. So you need to keep tuning in for his "calls".
This is the only way daytraders can make money:Quote from Bob111:
you can laugh anyway you like..until all of sudden your edge stops working for ya..ever heard about reverse engineering?
give me enough of your live calls\signals and i will be 1 cent ahead of you and buy all the shares right before you click your fucking buy button.
it's day trading, not some 1 year time frame investing. no wonder you can't make a dime in that field. cause you fucking clueless about reality of day trading. buy and hold and once in while got that right to score some $-that's your play field. try to make a dough every single day 5 days a week.
btw-you didn't show us your BIG $ "rebound score"
once again-post your PnL to prove that you not lying to us. Prove that you are profitable YTD..once again-i did post my account PnL for 2009, as a the proof that i did make money daytrading every single week for whole 2009. how about you? bring it on.sucker..until you post a screen shot-you are nothing, but a big mouth, full of BS.
Quote from crgarcia:
This is the only way daytraders can make money:
Fronrunning, which by the way is illegal.
The reality of daytrading is that its only recommended by churning brokers to generate commissions.
I profited BIG from the stock market rebound, buying during recession.
I posted a journal with REAL TIME TRADES.
(they were long term trades)
Quote from crgarcia:
This is the only way daytraders can make money:
Fronrunning, which by the way is illegal.
The reality of daytrading is that its only recommended by churning brokers to generate commissions.
It's because it's difficult to isolate a single factor in one's development as a trader. While a new trader may benefit from following someone else's real-time trades a whole lot, they probably also look at an occasional chart posted in one of the journals.. and read books.Quote from wrbtrader:
Posting real-time trades does not teach someone how to trade nor how to strike it rich...that's why there's minimal time loss on the part of the giver (real-time trade poster). There has not been one single person at Elitetrader.com that can show verifiable proof that their trading has improved after watching someone post real-time trades in comparison to their trading prior to watching the real-time poster...
Not one with verifiable proof.
Fully agree here. Comparing E-Peens is not eductional... unless you are a psychologist.Quote from wrbtrader:
Thus, the only usefulness of a challenge involving real-time trades is entertainment purpose only.
Just in case night trading counts here is my fill info. +2600.00 .. Gotta go, moms cooking breakfast. Let me know if you don't believe me cause I can pull it from the brokers website too. Also be sure to post a p/l from today, or some sort of trade/investment record for today.Quote from Speciaul_K:
You better look up the definition of frontrunning before you use it in a sentence. Don't want to look like a fool.
Im up over 1g tonight, but its only because im night trading not doing that dumb daytrading. Which leads me to ask, does night trading qualify for your challenge?