Quote from tea_leaf:
Thank you for your detailed reply, Jack. Is it possible to see the slower fractal on 5min TF?
Yes it is.
There is a lot to chart reading. Some people take years to be Comfortable.
Attached is Friday's chart, what I see on the slower fractal (using CW terminology) is a short ending and then an inverted saucer.
On the trading fractal I just went in long on the open and reversed on bar 4 to complete the long that was carried over.
To see the Depression we are in takes looking at a very slow fractal (the slowest ecomometrically speaking). But prgamtically, you are surrounded by traders a lot of which are on the wy out the bak door. Trading isn't for everyone and there is this strange crust around the perimeter.
Myths fester and con men become venders to the unwary. They make movies about sensational things and people.
But inside the FI, there is a servic industry that provides and gets paid. Most connectedness to markts via accounts and streams of reliable infomation.
To extend mankind tools are invented and used. A lot of people on ET think tools wear out. Others know that the correct tools do not wear out.
The catbird seat is a nice place to be. Immunity to BS is glorious, in fact.
So as you look at Friday as a short followed by an inverted saucer, let yourself step into the trading fractal where the full offer of the market may be taken.
There was a "normal" type trend from bar 4 to 19 (the c to a to b to c turns.) This was the first 20% of the day and 13 of the 21 points required to double capital happened. The open nailed 3 points before that.
so the day is a relaxed summer Friday and Price movement is going to double capital at least.
I did have a beginner ask me what happens when the system doesn't work. This is a money question and not a "how does the system of the operation of the market work" question. So at that time, I had to handle his not destroying any part of his mind irreversably. Below is what he experienced.
Between bar 19 and 34 the market was in a drift type (D) trend. No money to be made but a lot of science to be applied to "know you know", this was a: c to a to b to a to b to c type segment.
Type Set A trends followed and wrapped up on bars 37, 39, and 43.
Normal set C trends followed anding on bars 50 and 58.
Type Set A trends followed and wrapped up on bars 62,64, and 66.
the last three trades of the day were types B, B and A and ending on bars 70,72, and 77, respectively.
Every trend maks a fews points or keep you on the correct side of the market.
The account is going to be swept on Friday anyway and it is not unusual to pull quite a bit out to get back to the Monday starting level.
So the inverted saucer is a slower fractal container for the trading fractal trades. From trade to trade the type of trend changes.
Here are the things you always know you know bar by bar:
1. the price case.
2. the volume case.
3. what type of turn just happened and what possible turn is coming up.
4. what type of trend you are in.
5. by using the n-1 turn you know the n turn possibilities.
Everything is done with precision lookup tables. you have pages in a 3 ring binder. the pages are tabbed for convenience. you alway have the correct page open.
If you are a programmer, then when you read the above, you see it as an automated ATS that is takng the full offer of the market ALL the time EVERY DAY.
Movement has a context on several levels so you always know that you know.
Who cares what the system looks like as long as you start at the correct place.
People who do not have edges are meeting other people who do not have edges. Persons with edges avoid people who do not have edges. This is how winners and losers are winowed into to piles.
My chart (the first full day of our new trading room (shown on a wall screen)) shows we are using precision TA and making money all the time. Enjoy.
MS posted the normal and drift Modrian panels (4) as his top example of BS. He is one happy guy. Use his posted item to see the pairs (N-1 and N turns) Each set C or Set D type trend c turn is listed on that Modrian table.