No two traders trade identically. What you can gleam from other traders, published or not are ideas to test to incorporate into or in creation on you own trade plan. If Al's work resonates with you, test and perhaps use them, if not move on. Whether Al or anyone else makes money trading has little to do with your own prospects for success....that's up to you. I've read many books when I was trying to find my way, most of them have little or nothing to do with the way I trade but why waste time criticizing or whining about the material. Such "efforts" have no effect on whether or not you will make a living.