To those who claim to teach an edge and have the trading history to back it up, I salute you for being in a very small minority. I have evaluated many trading vendors over the past 15 years and I have not found one I would consider an edge provider. But of course, I haven't met everyone, so my experience is just over a sample of all the vendors out there.
Of course, I did not define what metrics really constitute an edge, e.g. avg win/loss ratio, percentage winners, consecutive losers, and my expectation that successful traders should attain great financial wealth as a result of their trading prowess. But rather than dive into those details as a challenge to compare any particular ET member against, I will let your postings stand as you represent yourselves with conviction, and let my general statement stand as my direct experience.