People like getting told to what to believe and not. No reasoning, just believe this, like a firing of a neuron (ironically), and be rewarded.
like people buying bitcoins???

People like getting told to what to believe and not. No reasoning, just believe this, like a firing of a neuron (ironically), and be rewarded.

The problem with being part of the herd is by the time the herd gets in the price is already half way up the move and by the time the herd gets out the price is already half way down. So you either end up break even or with a loss.
In contrast, when you anticipate a move and get in before the herd you have enough room to get out with a profit when the trend reverses.
I said big blocks being bought, not sold,at tops, and likewise large blocks being sold at bottoms. These blocks can be identified in T&S.
The concept of "herd" is overcooked...overstated..overused...overvalued..overpromoted. The herd is basically a few scraggly cows running around taking a dump every now and then. Todays markets are dominated by the institutions..HFT's ..etc. It is institutions trading against each other. At all times there are bullish institutions and bearish institutions in the market, at every price level. They all have their reasons. If you are one of the scraggly cows your job is to find the institution who is winning at the moment, latch onto it's tail, and be dragged along. Then let go quickly when the crap starts ejecting.%%like people buying bitcoins???![]()


%%
NO,the stock market is not like bitcon or tulip mania, even though looks like the short sellers when they may come into bitcon, + Enron there maybe some -patterns the same. LOL Stocks are part ownership of companies, not like a tulip mania @ all.![]()

%%tulip mania was dutch. there is a saying about that: if you did business with a dutchman and you got not scammed, it is because the dutchman forgot to do it.![]()

It can be one or many big traders getting it wrong at the top and buying, just as there are one or many getting it right and selling. If you think that all big traders always get it right, you might want to rethink that!
But in any event I do not consider or attach any importance as to who is doing what. You will wind up chasing your tail by trying to analyze the complexities of the market, to which, for the most part, the answer can only be imagined. The shorts are being squeezed, the AI at GS knows what your next order will be even before you do, XXX fund is accumulating YYY, A guru said buy ZZZ, B guru said sell it, etc. The real or imagined intrigue of the market can overwhelm one. But in the end, all that really counts is just the price movement itself, isn't it? IMO. And if that can be read, which it can be in most, but not all cases, what else do you need to know?
So rather than worry about who's doing what, your time might be better spent looking for your future ex-wife!!
Provided big traders can get it wrong then how come it would even be worthy to pay attention to the points at which the big orders are coming in? Or were you saying that it's not significant even though you have the potential to see these trades?
IMHO the most significant point is the price movement itself, and not who's buying/selling. And the point of my previous reply was simply that within the herd that buys at/near tops and sells at/near bottoms you can find GS just as well as somebody's Granny (no offense meant to any Grannies out there).Provided big traders can get it wrong then how come it would even be worthy to pay attention to the points at which the big orders are coming in? Or were you saying that it's not significant even though you have the potential to see these trades?
%%IMHO the most significant point is the price movement itself, and not who's buying/selling. And the point of my previous reply was simply that within the herd that buys at/near tops and sells at/near bottoms you can find GS just as well as somebody's Granny (no offense meant to any Grannies out there).
Just as many are, perhaps you are overly concerned about big orders believing that big equals smart guys, and that as the smart guys have all available information at their fingertips, they must be right!! Well, I can't count the times I heard security analysts scream "The market's got it all wrong".
Just buy/sell the trend, and you'll be with the smart guys, and a few smart Grannies too!!
