How can you even claim that technicals matter?

What annual rate of return would you be satisfied with from your trading?
How much total time would you willing to apply to both sharpening your skills, and to trading - per week?

At least 40%.

It depends if I can find something that I actually know will yield results over time. I know that I won't be able to watch charts all day. But I could possibly enter positions ahead of data releases or something? I'm willing to tweak the strategy.
 
.



There certainly situations where there is an 80% probability of price moving so far and in such a direction rather than doing otherwise. There are many situations where there is a 60% chance price will do one thing rather than the other. Why limit yourself to a roulette style edge when there is so much more available to you?

What about setting up trades around data releases? Either economic data or company earnings. But something like...

If unemployment is higher than expected, it would be a larger surprise than if it remained stable or the rate dropped slightly?

So a win would be a big win... A loss would be a slight loss.

Or for example, "betting" (guessing) that TSLA earnings would beat expectations. Imagine if I had a bunch of call options on TSLA with all that leverage the other day when it rose 11%.
 
Last edited:
Maybe ... but if over many many years, and a lot of hard work, you identify a repeating pattern of behavior that allows you take profits with some consistency, I bet you'd be very proud of that accomplishment. Rightfully so. And when some random person on social media demands that you teach them to do that in 5 easy steps ...... would you be glad to invest a lot of your time, away from your other interests, to turn that hard earned accomplishment over to them ? ... for free ? ... with no benefit to you ?

Of course not.

But from my perspective, I'm trying to make sure I don't spend lots of time and energy on something fruitless.
 
Part of me just wants to make random longer-term bets on hunches I have.

For example, I've always thought that the fears over Brexit were based on nothing. So perhaps the GBP is artificially depressed.

So I could take $10,000 that I can afford to lose and put it on the GBP. Then I would just need to know which currency to pick against.
 
Of course not.

But from my perspective, I'm trying to make sure I don't spend lots of time and energy on something fruitless.
TA works. It's math. No question. But not in a vacuum. All the TA in the world won't help if you can't/don't accept uncertainty. And understand expectancy as opposed to win rate. And learn to deal with decision fatigue. And... and... and...

All of which takes time to grow into.
 
Part of me just wants to make random longer-term bets on hunches I have.

Awk... gambling. There are long discussions on it as traders. Most consistently profitable traders I know personally don't think of what they do as gambling. Although they would not argue with anyone about it -- not worth their time (other than to pass time on ET!)
.

But everyone knows you can gamble as a trader. Over time gamblers lose.
 
Awk... gambling. There are long discussions on it as traders. Most traders I know personally don't think of what they do as gambling. Although they would not argue with anyone about it -- not worth their time (other than to pass time on ET!)
.

But everyone knows you can gamble as a trader. Over time gamblers lose.

This is what George Soros did. He made longer-term bets on what he thought would happen. He won more than he lost because his logic was accurate, I suppose.

But yes it is gambling to me. But I also haven't seen any way to make other strategies seem less like gambling.
 
Back
Top